Spanky, you make some excellent points !
But when you talk about being more experienced and qualified, you are talking about someone that is more experienced and qualified in some other school's program, not in our program, not in the last 5 years anyway. And this individual is probably from a different region of the country and maybe a different time zone that doesn't know Montana, GRIZ football, UM or the Pacific NW
And if he isn't, he's probably Beau Baldwin or someone very similar to him--already successful at this level and likely to just punch his ticket after 2-3 years and leave for an FBS job where he can triple or quadruple his salary.
Almost 30 years ago, the Bobcats cleaned house and hired Earle Solomonsen from NDSU, where he had won something like two Div. II NC's back when the Bison were still Div. II.
Earl was a good and decent man--I met him when I worked at The Holiday-Inn Parkside while attending UM, (The Cats were staying there for Cat-GRIZ), but he was from the Midwest, didn't understand Big Sky football, didn't know a lot of folks in Montana or the Pacific NW, and his wishbone offense floundered--this is all from memory. He lasted about 4 years--our streak against the Bobcats began with Earl as their HC, Don Read as ours.
In defense of The Bobcats, their program had started to fail after winning the NC in '84--the Cats could and did make an argument at that time for going outside the program for new blood.
We have no such excuse--our program after sputtering Mick's first year, improved last year and again this year, so I just don't see the need to go outside the program, kind of like our basketball team: Krysko, Tinks, Travis.