AZGrizFan said:
uofmman1122 said:
Don't get me wrong, I'm certainly happy with the jobs that Calhoun and Nash did stepping into the CB roles, but if the prospect of having two FBS drop down corners as starters worries you more than having two converted FCS WRs as starters did, that seems like a strange thing to be overly concerned about. Our corner play was not particularly stellar most of last season.
There's a really good chance that Corbin Walker would've beaten Nash out on the depth chart if he had stayed, anyways, and he'd potentially be looking at being the 4th guy in. With that in mind, the transfer makes a lot more sense.
Corbin walker could have/would have taken Calhoun's spot.
My fear is that drop downs frequently don't pan out. If THESE two don't pan out we're in deep doo doo...
As for Walker, I'm assuming that he and the two OSU corners moved ahead of Nash.
But anyway, do they frequently not pan out? And how do we define that? Are all non-starters dudes who didn't pan out? I guess we can use that distinction.
I thought I'd look because I genuinely am curious as to how often the drop downs we get pan out or not. I've highlighted secondary players, since that's what we're interested in seeing.
Drop downs since 2010 that (subjectively) didn't work out:
TJ Reynard (Wisconsin) - If I remember right, he came in off the bench mostly as a nickel.
Donald Bedell (Rutgers) - Was a role player off the bench most of his career.
Chris Favaroso (App State) - Being a little generous, but he did go to ASU his first season. Counting him as not working out because he left the team in 2018.
Kadeem Hemphill (SJSU) - Injuries took away a promising prospect.
Mason Vinyard (WSU) - Left team without playing.
Mykal Tolliver (Hawaii) - Jury is still out.
Drop downs since 2010 that did work out:
Tyrone Duncan (UDub) - Amazing DT for our 2010 and 2011 teams.
Markell Sanders (WSU) - Stepped in an played well in 2016 and 2017. Not a shut down corner, but arguably a better pure CB than Nash/Calhoun.
Yamen Sanders (UA) - I
do think that Sanders worked out, but I know he was a whipping boy for a lot of posters on here in 2015/2016. Played hurt for most of his career.
Justin Strong (OSU) - Was a pivotal part of the 2016 and 2017 secondaries.
James Banks (UAB) - IIRC, led the team in tackles in 2017.
David Shaw (Maryland) - Dude was a stud in the middle.
Gavin Robertson (UA) - Working out pretty great so far.
Reid Miller (Arkansas) - Played really well as a on again/off again starter.
Joe Babros (NC State) - Started a few games and did well before he got hurt.
Keynan Foster (UTEP) - Started as kick returner and did pretty well, although he's borderline for a CB.
10 out of 16 seems pretty good, and 6 out of 9 in the secondary is even better.
All of this is to say that I don't think Nash leaving should have anyone panicked just yet. It sucks because I liked the kid, but we're still +1 in total number of CBs than we were before Hicks-Onu and Cotton showed up, and I'm excited to see what these two more prototypical CBs bring to our defense.