cclarkblues said:
I don't understand your analogy. Spoons and guns are tools. They don't have free will as players do. That is one of the both wonderful and dangerous things about human beings. I'm sure there are many coaches that wish their players could be used as a tool to do with what they want. One caveat: RE IS a TOOL.
The point is the RE made the decision to fire the guys. He didn't have to fire them. He didn't even have good reason to fire them, in my view (and the view of many others). The several criminal things didn't force him to fire them. Except at Penn St, no president in the history of ncaa football has fired both the coach and AD at the same time. I assume you don't think UM's situation was the 2d worst criminal situation in the history of college sports.
RE over-reacted and made a huge mistake. UM is paying for that and other of his many mistakes. Their firings shouldn't, and I say can't, be blamed on some players. RE make the huge mistake.
His poor thinking and analysis was 90% plus of the mistake, compared to a relatively low percentage by the players. Note that of all the sexual assault (from rumors to major incidents), only 1 person went to jail (or was convicted or plead guilty). Only 1 other was even charged. They were the only 2 named in the police blotter (if JJ is included), in terms of sexual assault. Just a huge over-reaction. No player who was "charged" by UM for sexual assault and got a lawyer to fight the charges, was ever tossed out of school (I was told on good authority).