So will this officiating crew....

[AZGrizFan]

I'm not one for conspiracy theories but... I don't find it coincidental that this big play blunder was paired with the fact that ccu only received 1 penalty(that the side judge had to call when the back judge had a clear view of the pi and still didn't throw the flag on the obvious pi) while montana suffered MANY penalties, many of which are extremely controversial. I'm not sure what exactly happened but the ref bias wasn't just the bad replay, it was the entire game.

And anyone who said "ccu was better get over it" has no idea what they're talking about because the refs took 7 points off our board( which was enough to tie) and the griz were way overly penalized whereas ccu wasnt. Ccu very well COULD have been better but we will never know as the refs had too much of a factor

Montana had 5 penalties for 52 yards. In the 12 games prior they were flagged for 56 penalties for 576 yards....that's an average of roughly 4.5 penalties & just shy of 50 ypg. I wouldn't call that "over penalized".

 

[becker2117]

Jesus guys... criminal intent? Get over it. So the mistake made was that the refs should have stopped that play before it happened. It was a mistake, it happens. I agree they should be held accountable... but big deal, so should they get fired? Suspended for a game? Mandatory training? If so... I want the refs from Cat/Griz to get the same punishment for at least two blown calls in that game that certainly influenced the outcome.

Alright, i didnt even want to log in tonight but when i read this i had no choice but to say something. Officiating mistakes happen, this is true. This one i would dare to say has NEVER happened (at least i haven't seen or heard of it) since the inception of instant replay! This was so insane that nobody i was around even thought for one second that they reviewed the previous catch by Haynes...we were all totally clueless as to how an entire play was wiped out, no penalty no whistle no nothing. There will be blown PI calls, or holds (which we saw on multiple occasions saturday) along with many other bad calls. This is a fuck up that you will never see again! This is common knowledge among even casual fans.......Watching that replay there was no intent by anybody to stop that play, even if it occurred momentarily after the snap that would show the "page defense" was at least a decent excuse.

If you wanna say the griz didnt make the plays to win the game, fine....but this was one play that they executed to perfection that would have given them a shot to tie the game and take it to overtime, where we would have had extreme momentum....as we dominated play in the second half....if you wanna just chalk this up as a bad call and the team needs to get over it it certainly appears you are clueless or have some sort of agenda against UM football (we know you are out there)..this is 100% inexcusable by an officiating crew

 

[becker2117]

I had lunch with a college official yesterday, and asked him his take. This has been the talk of officiating circles around the country for the last three days.

In short, this was a major, major error on the part of the officials in this game. This should have never happened, and he said he has never seen (or even heard) of this happening before. This wasn’t the only critical error in this game, and the white-hat completely lost control at a few points in the game.

This was a poorly officiated game, for BOTH SIDES, it’s just that this call was so unordinary it sticks out in everyone’s mind. Henderson was out of bounds, and the PI call in the 4th when their safety was called for PI on Jamal Jones was ticky-tack at best.

It’s really unfortunate this call happened in this games, because for most Griz fans in masks why they actually lost this game.

You make it sound the real reason its unfortunate this call happened is so griz fans can make excuses.........are you so blinded that you fail to realize if no for this fuck up this game most likely (not for sure) goes into overtime?

How can you be so sure that we would have lost the game if it wasnt for this? This is a blunder that even an official u apparently had lunch with has NEVER seen before! The other ones...happen...ive seen NFL officials make extremely questionable over turns on replay..judgment errors happen.........this was a blatant disregard for the rules. You can sit on your maroon ivory tower and claim to be better than the rest of us griz fans who feel it impacted the game, but you are wrong. It had an effect on the possible outcome. No saying we would have won, but this is an error that can not and should NEVER be overlooked!

 

[becker2117]

I thought the PI call was a good call. Defender was early and interfered with the catch. Usually called, sometimes not.

The non-call holding were bad several times. The worst was the non-call on the CC sideline when Tripp was outside his blocker but unable to get away from him to push the runner out of bounds because he was being held blatantly by the blocker. Allowed CC to pick up an important 3d and long around midfield. These were all normal calls/missed calls, which happen in almost every game. The blunder on the replay situation was in a category of incompetence by itself.

Let’s say there was no replay in this game. On that play in question, JJ rolls out and starts to run, looks down field and hits his receiver for the same gain. BUT, there’s a flag on the play and they call an illegal forward pass because they thought JJ was over the line. Everyone watches the replay and it’s not even close. He was WELL behind the line and it’s 100% indisputable. Griz get hosed. Mistake by the ref, and there’s nothing you can do about it. THIS HAPPENS ALL THE TIME, and the end result is exactly the same as what happened on Saturday. So, WHY are you making such a big deal out of the replay mistake? WHY is it such a big deal to you? Would you STILL be whining about this one play if it were the above scenario? That’s fine if you all want to keep railing on and on about this and start a movement to get someone fired… but it’s not going to happen. What SHOULD happen is that this crew should be required to take a mandatory training course and intensive testing to make sure they understand how to properly implement instant replay in a game.

I know im getting in on this a little late.....but hahah! WHEN ON EARTH does this happen all the time? You might seen an illegal forward pass called once a year on a team IF THAT....and then its not something the officals are gunna call if he is clearly behind the LOS..haha you are really reaching right now...wow :shock:

 

[kurtismichael]

I thought the PI call was a good call. Defender was early and interfered with the catch. Usually called, sometimes not.

The non-call holding were bad several times. The worst was the non-call on the CC sideline when Tripp was outside his blocker but unable to get away from him to push the runner out of bounds because he was being held blatantly by the blocker. Allowed CC to pick up an important 3d and long around midfield. These were all normal calls/missed calls, which happen in almost every game. The blunder on the replay situation was in a category of incompetence by itself.

Let’s say there was no replay in this game. On that play in question, JJ rolls out and starts to run, looks down field and hits his receiver for the same gain. BUT, there’s a flag on the play and they call an illegal forward pass because they thought JJ was over the line. Everyone watches the replay and it’s not even close. He was WELL behind the line and it’s 100% indisputable. Griz get hosed. Mistake by the ref, and there’s nothing you can do about it. THIS HAPPENS ALL THE TIME, and the end result is exactly the same as what happened on Saturday. So, WHY are you making such a big deal out of the replay mistake? WHY is it such a big deal to you? Would you STILL be whining about this one play if it were the above scenario? That’s fine if you all want to keep railing on and on about this and start a movement to get someone fired… but it’s not going to happen. What SHOULD happen is that this crew should be required to take a mandatory training course and intensive testing to make sure they understand how to properly implement instant replay in a game.

I know im getting in on this a little late.....but hahah! WHEN ON EARTH does this happen all the time? You might seen an illegal forward pass called once a year on a team IF THAT....and then its not something the officals are gunna call if he is clearly behind the LOS..haha you are really reaching right now...wow :shock:

Hey Becker, how did the wheel barrel fire and elk steaks turn out? Better than the officiating I hope.
I know ff:

 

[Grizo406]

Speaking of Saturday's officiating crew, has anyone heard anything about what their "higher ups" thought about the job they did/didn't do in the CCU/Griz game?

I don't know where to begin looking for it, but there' gotta' be something on the inter-web about it, right?!!?

 

[George Ferguson]

Griz-o...It's the FCS, no one cares about the FCS, remember? So no, you won't find anything formal on the net about this issue. This would have never happened if the Griz would have moved to the WACK. The officials in the WACK are the real deal and never f--k up. Of course, the Griz wouldn't have been playing a Dec. 7 home game if they were a member of the WACK either.

 

[becker2117]

I thought the PI call was a good call. Defender was early and interfered with the catch. Usually called, sometimes not.

The non-call holding were bad several times. The worst was the non-call on the CC sideline when Tripp was outside his blocker but unable to get away from him to push the runner out of bounds because he was being held blatantly by the blocker. Allowed CC to pick up an important 3d and long around midfield. These were all normal calls/missed calls, which happen in almost every game. The blunder on the replay situation was in a category of incompetence by itself.

Let’s say there was no replay in this game. On that play in question, JJ rolls out and starts to run, looks down field and hits his receiver for the same gain. BUT, there’s a flag on the play and they call an illegal forward pass because they thought JJ was over the line. Everyone watches the replay and it’s not even close. He was WELL behind the line and it’s 100% indisputable. Griz get hosed. Mistake by the ref, and there’s nothing you can do about it. THIS HAPPENS ALL THE TIME, and the end result is exactly the same as what happened on Saturday. So, WHY are you making such a big deal out of the replay mistake? WHY is it such a big deal to you? Would you STILL be whining about this one play if it were the above scenario? That’s fine if you all want to keep railing on and on about this and start a movement to get someone fired… but it’s not going to happen. What SHOULD happen is that this crew should be required to take a mandatory training course and intensive testing to make sure they understand how to properly implement instant replay in a game.

I know im getting in on this a little late.....but hahah! WHEN ON EARTH does this happen all the time? You might seen an illegal forward pass called once a year on a team IF THAT....and then its not something the officals are gunna call if he is clearly behind the LOS..haha you are really reaching right now...wow :shock:

Hey Becker, how did the wheel barrel fire and elk steaks turn out? Better than the officiating I hope.
I know ff:

It was really fun! The day other than us losing was great...griz win and it goes down as an epic day in my life......ahhh what the hell, it was epic anyway! ....i loaded up the wheelbarrow and coals that i thought i drowned out......and started talking with some people passing by...15 mins later, i saw smoke rolling out of my front window! note to self, next time bring a pickup! haha

 

[kurtismichael]

Let’s say there was no replay in this game. On that play in question, JJ rolls out and starts to run, looks down field and hits his receiver for the same gain. BUT, there’s a flag on the play and they call an illegal forward pass because they thought JJ was over the line. Everyone watches the replay and it’s not even close. He was WELL behind the line and it’s 100% indisputable. Griz get hosed. Mistake by the ref, and there’s nothing you can do about it. THIS HAPPENS ALL THE TIME, and the end result is exactly the same as what happened on Saturday. So, WHY are you making such a big deal out of the replay mistake? WHY is it such a big deal to you? Would you STILL be whining about this one play if it were the above scenario? That’s fine if you all want to keep railing on and on about this and start a movement to get someone fired… but it’s not going to happen. What SHOULD happen is that this crew should be required to take a mandatory training course and intensive testing to make sure they understand how to properly implement instant replay in a game.

I know im getting in on this a little late.....but hahah! WHEN ON EARTH does this happen all the time? You might seen an illegal forward pass called once a year on a team IF THAT....and then its not something the officals are gunna call if he is clearly behind the LOS..haha you are really reaching right now...wow :shock:

Hey Becker, how did the wheel barrel fire and elk steaks turn out? Better than the officiating I hope.
I know ff:

It was really fun! The day other than us losing was great...griz win and it goes down as an epic day in my life......ahhh what the hell, it was epic anyway! ....i loaded up the wheelbarrow and coals that i thought i drowned out......and started talking with some people passing by...15 mins later, i saw smoke rolling out of my front window! note to self, next time bring a pickup! haha

I was going to try to stop by but we were pretty frozen by the time we got from downtown to Hammer's fire.

Besides losing the only bad part of the day was my beer freezing in the can before I could finish it. First time I've ever drank slushy beer.

 

[Fahque]

Ball never touches the ground!

Reread the bold! nothing to do with the ball touching the ground, he is bobbling the ball as he is going out of bounds. A foot would be considered any part of his body.
you can not see going frame by frame when his left foot is out of bounds, on the ground, yet there is no control when his right foot touches in bounds, in fact he doesn't gain control of the ball until he is another step out of bounds.

There is no evidence to over rule the call on the field. Remember it has to be indisputable. If the refs would have called it a catch, a person could argue the other way, until you look at the pictures and description below.

My point was the announcers were incorrect when the stated the ruling as you.

Here are two photos the first shows the left foot on the ground(look at the arrow) before the right foot scrapes down in bounds. The second photo shows the left foot (look at the arrow) after the right foot is coming off the ground for the next step. How do you know the right foot hit the ground first? The foot is in the exact same spot even though his body is moving from left to right. Impossible not to be the first foot down out of bounds.










here is the ball out in the sequence showing no control, fuzz but you can tell.

Dude let it go. We get it he was out of bounds. You're trying so hard to convince us that we got 1 call thus the officials fairly officiated the game. There were too many officiating blunders and this catch was one of VERY many.

You are correct they were blunders, everyone needs to realize it wasn't one sided. This play actually did put points on the board that shouldn't have been. The game was won by CCU, not lost due to the refs. Every game someone loses they complain about the refs and forget the calls they do get. It is ridiculous. You could go through every play with a microscope and probably find penalties. Sometimes officials are out of position, or just didn't see it from their angle. We hear it every week the BSC refs suck, the Southland suck, etc. It is what it is. If they were better they would more than likely be in the BCS of Division 1 or NFL.

STFU already. You keep arguing the same points that pretty much everybody here has already agreed to yet you argue them like we haven't. We know that the review play did not lose us the game or many of the other bad calls for that matter. However, we are talking about the review play so much because it is blatantly obvious that the referees obviously did not know what they were doing or blatantly decided to disregard the review rules. Is that so hard to understand?. Have you ever seen it happen in a game before at any level?

 

[Bertram]

http://sports.yahoo.com/blogs/ncaaf...s-playoff-game-wipes-15-230302146--ncaaf.html Yahoo Sports did an article on this

 

[poorgriz]

I thought the PI call was a good call. Defender was early and interfered with the catch. Usually called, sometimes not.

The non-call holding were bad several times. The worst was the non-call on the CC sideline when Tripp was outside his blocker but unable to get away from him to push the runner out of bounds because he was being held blatantly by the blocker. Allowed CC to pick up an important 3d and long around midfield. These were all normal calls/missed calls, which happen in almost every game. The blunder on the replay situation was in a category of incompetence by itself.

Let’s say there was no replay in this game. On that play in question, JJ rolls out and starts to run, looks down field and hits his receiver for the same gain. BUT, there’s a flag on the play and they call an illegal forward pass because they thought JJ was over the line. Everyone watches the replay and it’s not even close. He was WELL behind the line and it’s 100% indisputable. Griz get hosed. Mistake by the ref, and there’s nothing you can do about it. THIS HAPPENS ALL THE TIME, and the end result is exactly the same as what happened on Saturday. So, WHY are you making such a big deal out of the replay mistake? WHY is it such a big deal to you? Would you STILL be whining about this one play if it were the above scenario? That’s fine if you all want to keep railing on and on about this and start a movement to get someone fired… but it’s not going to happen. What SHOULD happen is that this crew should be required to take a mandatory training course and intensive testing to make sure they understand how to properly implement instant replay in a game.

I know im getting in on this a little late.....but hahah! WHEN ON EARTH does this happen all the time? You might seen an illegal forward pass called once a year on a team IF THAT....and then its not something the officals are gunna call if he is clearly behind the LOS..haha you are really reaching right now...wow :shock:

Yes... I hate to break it to you, but refs make mistakes ALL THE TIME. Some of them completely eliminate good gains, or even worse than what happened to you, touchdowns... turnovers... PICK 6's (Cat\griz). especially in the FCS when we don't get instant replay until playoffs... the TV replays often clearly show massive F ups from the officials. So my whole point of the thread above was... why the outrage about this particular mistake by a crew that are obviously not very well trained on how to use instant replay, when there are many more examples of officiating mistakes that are just as costly or worse.

 

[Fahque]

I thought the PI call was a good call. Defender was early and interfered with the catch. Usually called, sometimes not.

The non-call holding were bad several times. The worst was the non-call on the CC sideline when Tripp was outside his blocker but unable to get away from him to push the runner out of bounds because he was being held blatantly by the blocker. Allowed CC to pick up an important 3d and long around midfield. These were all normal calls/missed calls, which happen in almost every game. The blunder on the replay situation was in a category of incompetence by itself.

Let’s say there was no replay in this game. On that play in question, JJ rolls out and starts to run, looks down field and hits his receiver for the same gain. BUT, there’s a flag on the play and they call an illegal forward pass because they thought JJ was over the line. Everyone watches the replay and it’s not even close. He was WELL behind the line and it’s 100% indisputable. Griz get hosed. Mistake by the ref, and there’s nothing you can do about it. THIS HAPPENS ALL THE TIME, and the end result is exactly the same as what happened on Saturday. So, WHY are you making such a big deal out of the replay mistake? WHY is it such a big deal to you? Would you STILL be whining about this one play if it were the above scenario? That’s fine if you all want to keep railing on and on about this and start a movement to get someone fired… but it’s not going to happen. What SHOULD happen is that this crew should be required to take a mandatory training course and intensive testing to make sure they understand how to properly implement instant replay in a game.

I know im getting in on this a little late.....but hahah! WHEN ON EARTH does this happen all the time? You might seen an illegal forward pass called once a year on a team IF THAT....and then its not something the officals are gunna call if he is clearly behind the LOS..haha you are really reaching right now...wow :shock:

Yes... I hate to break it to you, but refs make mistakes ALL THE TIME. Some of them completely eliminate good gains, or even worse than what happened to you, touchdowns... turnovers... PICK 6's (Cat\griz). especially in the FCS when we don't get instant replay until playoffs... the TV replays often clearly show massive F ups from the officials. So my whole point of the thread above was... why the outrage about this particular mistake by a crew that are obviously not very well trained on how to use instant replay, when there are many more examples of officiating mistakes that are just as costly or worse.

This entire thread as well as the 50 others on this very play aren't about the refs making a bad call you dumb fukc. It's about their blatant disregard of the replay rules. Now the missed calls were bad no calls, probably both ways. The Henderson catch, that was probably a bad call too but at least that one was reviewed right away and not after the next play was run and spotted.

 

[Robsnotes4u]

Reread the bold! nothing to do with the ball touching the ground, he is bobbling the ball as he is going out of bounds. A foot would be considered any part of his body.
you can not see going frame by frame when his left foot is out of bounds, on the ground, yet there is no control when his right foot touches in bounds, in fact he doesn't gain control of the ball until he is another step out of bounds.

There is no evidence to over rule the call on the field. Remember it has to be indisputable. If the refs would have called it a catch, a person could argue the other way, until you look at the pictures and description below.

My point was the announcers were incorrect when the stated the ruling as you.

Here are two photos the first shows the left foot on the ground(look at the arrow) before the right foot scrapes down in bounds. The second photo shows the left foot (look at the arrow) after the right foot is coming off the ground for the next step. How do you know the right foot hit the ground first? The foot is in the exact same spot even though his body is moving from left to right. Impossible not to be the first foot down out of bounds.










here is the ball out in the sequence showing no control, fuzz but you can tell.

Dude let it go. We get it he was out of bounds. You're trying so hard to convince us that we got 1 call thus the officials fairly officiated the game. There were too many officiating blunders and this catch was one of VERY many.

You are correct they were blunders, everyone needs to realize it wasn't one sided. This play actually did put points on the board that shouldn't have been. The game was won by CCU, not lost due to the refs. Every game someone loses they complain about the refs and forget the calls they do get. It is ridiculous. You could go through every play with a microscope and probably find penalties. Sometimes officials are out of position, or just didn't see it from their angle. We hear it every week the BSC refs suck, the Southland suck, etc. It is what it is. If they were better they would more than likely be in the BCS of Division 1 or NFL.

STFU already. You keep arguing the same points that pretty much everybody here has already agreed to yet you argue them like we haven't. We know that the review play did not lose us the game or many of the other bad calls for that matter. However, we are talking about the review play so much because it is blatantly obvious that the referees obviously did not know what they were doing or blatantly decided to disregard the review rules. Is that so hard to understand?. Have you ever seen it happen in a game before at any level?

You are classless. Quit whining.

 

[Fahque]

Dude let it go. We get it he was out of bounds. You're trying so hard to convince us that we got 1 call thus the officials fairly officiated the game. There were too many officiating blunders and this catch was one of VERY many.

You are correct they were blunders, everyone needs to realize it wasn't one sided. This play actually did put points on the board that shouldn't have been. The game was won by CCU, not lost due to the refs. Every game someone loses they complain about the refs and forget the calls they do get. It is ridiculous. You could go through every play with a microscope and probably find penalties. Sometimes officials are out of position, or just didn't see it from their angle. We hear it every week the BSC refs suck, the Southland suck, etc. It is what it is. If they were better they would more than likely be in the BCS of Division 1 or NFL.

STFU already. You keep arguing the same points that pretty much everybody here has already agreed to yet you argue them like we haven't. We know that the review play did not lose us the game or many of the other bad calls for that matter. However, we are talking about the review play so much because it is blatantly obvious that the referees obviously did not know what they were doing or blatantly decided to disregard the review rules. Is that so hard to understand?. Have you ever seen it happen in a game before at any level?

You are classless. Quit whining.

Not whining at all, you and poorgriz are just trying to turn this thread into something it's not because you two can't get it through your thick skulls what was actually being discussed here. Now that's classless.

 

[PlayerRep]

On the UM video, there's evidence that it was a catch. Call/ruling could have gone either way.

 

[ALPHAGRIZ1]

Only in your world.

The refs made the right call on the field, then replay screwed CCU.

 

[Robsnotes4u]

Ball never touches the ground!

Reread the bold! nothing to do with the ball touching the ground, he is bobbling the ball as he is going out of bounds. A foot would be considered any part of his body.
you can not see going frame by frame when his left foot is out of bounds, on the ground, yet there is no control when his right foot touches in bounds, in fact he doesn't gain control of the ball until he is another step out of bounds.

There is no evidence to over rule the call on the field. Remember it has to be indisputable. If the refs would have called it a catch, a person could argue the other way, until you look at the pictures and description below.

My point was the announcers were incorrect when the stated the ruling as you.

Here are two photos the first shows the left foot on the ground(look at the arrow) before the right foot scrapes down in bounds. The second photo shows the left foot (look at the arrow) after the right foot is coming off the ground for the next step. How do you know the right foot hit the ground first? The foot is in the exact same spot even though his body is moving from left to right. Impossible not to be the first foot down out of bounds.










here is the ball out in the sequence showing no control, fuzz but you can tell.

Dude let it go. We get it he was out of bounds. You're trying so hard to convince us that we got 1 call thus the officials fairly officiated the game. There were too many officiating blunders and this catch was one of VERY many.

You are correct they were blunders, everyone needs to realize it wasn't one sided. This play actually did put points on the board that shouldn't have been. The game was won by CCU, not lost due to the refs. Every game someone loses they complain about the refs and forget the calls they do get. It is ridiculous. You could go through every play with a microscope and probably find penalties. Sometimes officials are out of position, or just didn't see it from their angle. We hear it every week the BSC refs suck, the Southland suck, etc. It is what it is. If they were better they would more than likely be in the BCS of Division 1 or NFL.

On the UM video, there's evidence that it was a catch. Call/ruling could have gone either way.

look at post 73, read the explanation and look at the first to pictures. If you then think it is a catch. There is no argument. If a body part hits out of bounds before a part hits inbounds you are out.

 

[Eriul]

Reread the bold! nothing to do with the ball touching the ground, he is bobbling the ball as he is going out of bounds. A foot would be considered any part of his body.
you can not see going frame by frame when his left foot is out of bounds, on the ground, yet there is no control when his right foot touches in bounds, in fact he doesn't gain control of the ball until he is another step out of bounds.

There is no evidence to over rule the call on the field. Remember it has to be indisputable. If the refs would have called it a catch, a person could argue the other way, until you look at the pictures and description below.

My point was the announcers were incorrect when the stated the ruling as you.

Here are two photos the first shows the left foot on the ground(look at the arrow) before the right foot scrapes down in bounds. The second photo shows the left foot (look at the arrow) after the right foot is coming off the ground for the next step. How do you know the right foot hit the ground first? The foot is in the exact same spot even though his body is moving from left to right. Impossible not to be the first foot down out of bounds.










here is the ball out in the sequence showing no control, fuzz but you can tell.

Dude let it go. We get it he was out of bounds. You're trying so hard to convince us that we got 1 call thus the officials fairly officiated the game. There were too many officiating blunders and this catch was one of VERY many.

You are correct they were blunders, everyone needs to realize it wasn't one sided. This play actually did put points on the board that shouldn't have been. The game was won by CCU, not lost due to the refs. Every game someone loses they complain about the refs and forget the calls they do get. It is ridiculous. You could go through every play with a microscope and probably find penalties. Sometimes officials are out of position, or just didn't see it from their angle. We hear it every week the BSC refs suck, the Southland suck, etc. It is what it is. If they were better they would more than likely be in the BCS of Division 1 or NFL.

On the UM video, there's evidence that it was a catch. Call/ruling could have gone either way.

look at post 73, read the explanation and look at the first to pictures. If you then think it is a catch. There is no argument. If a body part hits out of bounds before a part hits inbounds you are out.

Jesus dude, you're still talking about the catch out of bounds? There is no proof he was out of bounds and you're trying SO GOD DAMN HARD to prove it to people when no one is really arguing with you. You put it on Youtube, you sent me a PM about it. Let it go fuck man. It's been a week. No one gives a FLYING FUCK about that catch, the only thing people are discussing is the HORRIBLE blunder to review the play 2 plays later.

 

[horribilisfan8184]

Dude let it go. We get it he was out of bounds. You're trying so hard to convince us that we got 1 call thus the officials fairly officiated the game. There were too many officiating blunders and this catch was one of VERY many.

You are correct they were blunders, everyone needs to realize it wasn't one sided. This play actually did put points on the board that shouldn't have been. The game was won by CCU, not lost due to the refs. Every game someone loses they complain about the refs and forget the calls they do get. It is ridiculous. You could go through every play with a microscope and probably find penalties. Sometimes officials are out of position, or just didn't see it from their angle. We hear it every week the BSC refs suck, the Southland suck, etc. It is what it is. If they were better they would more than likely be in the BCS of Division 1 or NFL.

On the UM video, there's evidence that it was a catch. Call/ruling could have gone either way.

look at post 73, read the explanation and look at the first to pictures. If you then think it is a catch. There is no argument. If a body part hits out of bounds before a part hits inbounds you are out.

Jesus dude, you're still talking about the catch out of bounds? There is no proof he was out of bounds and you're trying SO GOD DAMN HARD to prove it to people when no one is really arguing with you. You put it on Youtube, you sent me a PM about it. Let it go f*** man. It's been a week. No one gives a FLYING f*** about that catch, the only thing people are discussing is the HORRIBLE blunder to review the play 2 plays later.

Face it. Some people like their dead horse tenderized....