So will this officiating crew....

[Eriul]

You are correct they were blunders, everyone needs to realize it wasn't one sided. This play actually did put points on the board that shouldn't have been. The game was won by CCU, not lost due to the refs. Every game someone loses they complain about the refs and forget the calls they do get. It is ridiculous. You could go through every play with a microscope and probably find penalties. Sometimes officials are out of position, or just didn't see it from their angle. We hear it every week the BSC refs suck, the Southland suck, etc. It is what it is. If they were better they would more than likely be in the BCS of Division 1 or NFL.

On the UM video, there's evidence that it was a catch. Call/ruling could have gone either way.

look at post 73, read the explanation and look at the first to pictures. If you then think it is a catch. There is no argument. If a body part hits out of bounds before a part hits inbounds you are out.

Jesus dude, you're still talking about the catch out of bounds? There is no proof he was out of bounds and you're trying SO GOD DAMN HARD to prove it to people when no one is really arguing with you. You put it on Youtube, you sent me a PM about it. Let it go f*** man. It's been a week. No one gives a FLYING f*** about that catch, the only thing people are discussing is the HORRIBLE blunder to review the play 2 plays later.

Face it. Some people like their dead horse tenderized....

What's interesting is he said he was "at the NDSU" game last week so if that's the case the only time he watched this play he's bitching about was on replay. Not live, not in the stadium, yet he's bitching about it when he wasn't even watching us

 

[jodcon]

You are correct they were blunders, everyone needs to realize it wasn't one sided. This play actually did put points on the board that shouldn't have been. The game was won by CCU, not lost due to the refs. Every game someone loses they complain about the refs and forget the calls they do get. It is ridiculous. You could go through every play with a microscope and probably find penalties. Sometimes officials are out of position, or just didn't see it from their angle. We hear it every week the BSC refs suck, the Southland suck, etc. It is what it is. If they were better they would more than likely be in the BCS of Division 1 or NFL.

On the UM video, there's evidence that it was a catch. Call/ruling could have gone either way.

look at post 73, read the explanation and look at the first to pictures. If you then think it is a catch. There is no argument. If a body part hits out of bounds before a part hits inbounds you are out.

Jesus dude, you're still talking about the catch out of bounds? There is no proof he was out of bounds and you're trying SO GOD DAMN HARD to prove it to people when no one is really arguing with you. You put it on Youtube, you sent me a PM about it. Let it go f*** man. It's been a week. No one gives a FLYING f*** about that catch, the only thing people are discussing is the HORRIBLE blunder to review the play 2 plays later.

Face it. Some people like their dead horse tenderized....

Maybe this will come in handy.

 

[Robsnotes4u]

Dude let it go. We get it he was out of bounds. You're trying so hard to convince us that we got 1 call thus the officials fairly officiated the game. There were too many officiating blunders and this catch was one of VERY many.

You are correct they were blunders, everyone needs to realize it wasn't one sided. This play actually did put points on the board that shouldn't have been. The game was won by CCU, not lost due to the refs. Every game someone loses they complain about the refs and forget the calls they do get. It is ridiculous. You could go through every play with a microscope and probably find penalties. Sometimes officials are out of position, or just didn't see it from their angle. We hear it every week the BSC refs suck, the Southland suck, etc. It is what it is. If they were better they would more than likely be in the BCS of Division 1 or NFL.

On the UM video, there's evidence that it was a catch. Call/ruling could have gone either way.

look at post 73, read the explanation and look at the first to pictures. If you then think it is a catch. There is no argument. If a body part hits out of bounds before a part hits inbounds you are out.

Jesus dude, you're still talking about the catch out of bounds? There is no proof he was out of bounds and you're trying SO GOD DAMN HARD to prove it to people when no one is really arguing with you. You put it on Youtube, you sent me a PM about it. Let it go f*** man. It's been a week. No one gives a FLYING f*** about that catch, the only thing people are discussing is the HORRIBLE blunder to review the play 2 plays later.

really a hole look a couple posts above yours

 

[Robsnotes4u]

look at post 73, read the explanation and look at the first to pictures. If you then think it is a catch. There is no argument. If a body part hits out of bounds before a part hits inbounds you are out.

Jesus dude, you're still talking about the catch out of bounds? There is no proof he was out of bounds and you're trying SO GOD DAMN HARD to prove it to people when no one is really arguing with you. You put it on Youtube, you sent me a PM about it. Let it go f*** man. It's been a week. No one gives a FLYING f*** about that catch, the only thing people are discussing is the HORRIBLE blunder to review the play 2 plays later.

Face it. Some people like their dead horse tenderized....

What's interesting is he said he was "at the NDSU" game last week so if that's the case the only time he watched this play he's bitching about was on replay. Not live, not in the stadium, yet he's bitching about it when he wasn't even watching us

so the him an eye is better than replays or stop photos? Why do they have replay and slow mo then?

Did you watch any games on ESPN? Must be weird not knowing how the rest of the FCS is doing since you don't watch any outside games.

 

[AllWeatherFan]

Show of hands - how many people care if he was in bounds or out?

 

[PlayerRep]

Jesus dude, you're still talking about the catch out of bounds? There is no proof he was out of bounds and you're trying SO GOD DAMN HARD to prove it to people when no one is really arguing with you. You put it on Youtube, you sent me a PM about it. Let it go f*** man. It's been a week. No one gives a FLYING f*** about that catch, the only thing people are discussing is the HORRIBLE blunder to review the play 2 plays later.

Face it. Some people like their dead horse tenderized....

What's interesting is he said he was "at the NDSU" game last week so if that's the case the only time he watched this play he's bitching about was on replay. Not live, not in the stadium, yet he's bitching about it when he wasn't even watching us

so the him an eye is better than replays or stop photos? Why do they have replay and slow mo then?

Did you watch any games on ESPN? Must be weird not knowing how the rest of the FCS is doing since you don't watch any outside games.

Best video was UM's game tape. Showed there was justification for calling it a catch or not. Different/better than the tv angle. Jeez, the review official had the best view at the time of the call, and he called it a catch. Don't think the view from inside the Fargo Dome was as good as what the review official had.