statler & waldorf
Well-known member
Based on what he didn't do, perhaps the title left off, unintentionally of course, "...a novel by Jon Krakauer."
statler & waldorf said:Based on what he didn't do, perhaps the title left off, unintentionally of course, "...a novel by Jon Krakauer."
biga75 said:EverettGriz said:biga75 said:EverettGriz said:I'm very curious how one even begin to write this book without speaking to the prosecutor, the police chief or the university president . I get that for most issues, he simply used the public record. But wouldn't he eventually have a follow up question or two?
I guess if there's any good news it's that he also didn't speak with Florio.
I would be willing to bet she had a very significant role in getting this book to print. If that is the case, I highly doubt that it will ever be made public. :twocents:
I doubt she'd lie to her former employer (the Missoulian) about whether or not she was interviewed. Missoula's still a pretty small place, and a lie like that could severely damage your career as a reporter/professor.
Frankly, I think Krakauer is a huuuuuuge ego-maniac, and he simply doesn't believe he needs input from others to write a book.
I'll admit I only glossed over this morning's Missoulian article and must have missed this snippet provided by PR: "Former reporter Gwen Florio, now a published author who teaches reporting at the UM School of Journalism, said she also was not contacted. No one else from the newspaper has been contacted either."
It would make for a better story if she was involved though... :ugeek:
EverettGriz said:biga75 said:EverettGriz said:I'm very curious how one even begin to write this book without speaking to the prosecutor, the police chief or the university president . I get that for most issues, he simply used the public record. But wouldn't he eventually have a follow up question or two?
I guess if there's any good news it's that he also didn't speak with Florio.
I would be willing to bet she had a very significant role in getting this book to print. If that is the case, I highly doubt that it will ever be made public. :twocents:
I doubt she'd lie to her former employer (the Missoulian) about whether or not she was interviewed. Missoula's still a pretty small place, and a lie like that could severely damage your career as a reporter/professor.
Frankly, I think Krakauer is a huuuuuuge ego-maniac, and he simply doesn't believe he needs input from others to write a book.
PlayerRep said:AZGrizFan said:MrTitleist said:Another article this morning... it does not appear anyone was interviewed for this book. Not sure where Krakauer is getting his "sources with direct information" as none of the main players involved in JJs case have been contacted.
http://missoulian.com/news/local/missoula-hyperventilating-about-krakauer-book-on-rapes/article_363ca6a1-6a04-5094-ae7e-4589a13eab83.html" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
Seems to me like JJ might have a great case for libel/slander/character assassination.
Lawyers? What say ye...
It would depend on exactly what is said and whether what is said is not true. I don't think cherry-picking equals defamation, but don't know defamation law well enough to know for sure. While I can't imagine that Krakauer and the publisher would be so stupid and careless as to defame someone in a book like, I also doubt that they understand how bad Kraukauer could get clobbered (i.e. big damages) in a lawsuit in Montana.
poorgriz said:EverettGriz said:biga75 said:EverettGriz said:I'm very curious how one even begin to write this book without speaking to the prosecutor, the police chief or the university president . I get that for most issues, he simply used the public record. But wouldn't he eventually have a follow up question or two?
I guess if there's any good news it's that he also didn't speak with Florio.
I would be willing to bet she had a very significant role in getting this book to print. If that is the case, I highly doubt that it will ever be made public. :twocents:
I doubt she'd lie to her former employer (the Missoulian) about whether or not she was interviewed. Missoula's still a pretty small place, and a lie like that could severely damage your career as a reporter/professor.
Frankly, I think Krakauer is a huuuuuuge ego-maniac, and he simply doesn't believe he needs input from others to write a book.
Correct, and he's right. He can write whatever the F he wants.
PlayerRep said:But it is dishonest to say that it is well-researched. Maybe we'll get some Brian Williams pieces, like what he saw or heard in the courtroom.
PlayerRep said:biga75 said:EverettGriz said:biga75 said:I would be willing to bet she had a very significant role in getting this book to print. If that is the case, I highly doubt that it will ever be made public. :twocents:
I doubt she'd lie to her former employer (the Missoulian) about whether or not she was interviewed. Missoula's still a pretty small place, and a lie like that could severely damage your career as a reporter/professor.
Frankly, I think Krakauer is a huuuuuuge ego-maniac, and he simply doesn't believe he needs input from others to write a book.
I'll admit I only glossed over this morning's Missoulian article and must have missed this snippet provided by PR: "Former reporter Gwen Florio, now a published author who teaches reporting at the UM School of Journalism, said she also was not contacted. No one else from the newspaper has been contacted either."
It would make for a better story if she was involved though... :ugeek:
It surprised me that Florio was not contacted. There must have been some strategy behind that. I can't think of what it may have been.
horribilisfan8184 said:This same narrative, proved false in several instances lately nationally, has lost any public interest. While Missoula is in a sky fall over this impending book release it is really not news anywhere else. Get over yourselves, quit gnashing and wailing, and wait for the thud of book sales hitting the bottom of the outhouse come April. The only people who will buy this book already believe this happens at every college. Half of those people won't buy it because they don't know how to pronounce the town, or think Western Montana still doesn't have electricity or running water.....
AllWeatherFan said:if this thread reaches 17 pages, will that officially constitute a "tizzy?" Anybody know?
getgrizzy said:this response was in the missoulian...
Reed - February 23, 2015 11:15 pm
The University of Montana has been in steady decline for over a decade. It has been rotting from the inside. A college should not exist for a team. If teams are to exist at all, their members should be held to a higher standard than the average student. If winning a ball game is more important than educating the next generation then your society is doomed.
The "team" is a liability and always has been. Its a money-making scheme for good-ol-boys paid for by indebted students who are receiving a worthless education. The dropout rate and joblessness rate of actual graduates is abysmal.
On top of all the systemic problems at the U, there was always the notoriously sketchy Missoula PD. The police in Missoula are known nationwide for their misconduct. This is not just an issue relating to this rape accusation. The U has never had a "rape culture" and everyone knows it. The U has a Griz problem and a local-police problem. The Missoula PD just thought they could do what they always have done, which is cover-up for their buddies awhile generating revenue off the student population, which offers an endless stream of minor offenses to profit and expand upon. In this case, they got caught and people noticed. Hilariously few Missoulians "get it" but luckily Krakauer did.
The Missoulian is frequently complicit in this social rot with their inability to deliver hard-hitting reporting that improves the town. They are all-too afraid of Missoula's precious "reputation." Well it looks like Krakauer just flushed that reputation, so you may as well start realtalking before these issues get even worse. New (female) prosecutor won't change much. The problem is in the police and the U. Hopefully, that is exactly what the book is about.
Looks like Gwen is writing in the Missoulian again....PlayerRep said:getgrizzy said:this response was in the missoulian...
Reed - February 23, 2015 11:15 pm
The University of Montana has been in steady decline for over a decade. It has been rotting from the inside. A college should not exist for a team. If teams are to exist at all, their members should be held to a higher standard than the average student. If winning a ball game is more important than educating the next generation then your society is doomed.
The "team" is a liability and always has been. Its a money-making scheme for good-ol-boys paid for by indebted students who are receiving a worthless education. The dropout rate and joblessness rate of actual graduates is abysmal.
On top of all the systemic problems at the U, there was always the notoriously sketchy Missoula PD. The police in Missoula are known nationwide for their misconduct. This is not just an issue relating to this rape accusation. The U has never had a "rape culture" and everyone knows it. The U has a Griz problem and a local-police problem. The Missoula PD just thought they could do what they always have done, which is cover-up for their buddies awhile generating revenue off the student population, which offers an endless stream of minor offenses to profit and expand upon. In this case, they got caught and people noticed. Hilariously few Missoulians "get it" but luckily Krakauer did.
The Missoulian is frequently complicit in this social rot with their inability to deliver hard-hitting reporting that improves the town. They are all-too afraid of Missoula's precious "reputation." Well it looks like Krakauer just flushed that reputation, so you may as well start realtalking before these issues get even worse. New (female) prosecutor won't change much. The problem is in the police and the U. Hopefully, that is exactly what the book is about.
What an idiot. Virtually everything in the letter is incorrect and not supported by fact or anything. That person is a total loser, in my view.
PlayerRep said:getgrizzy said:this response was in the missoulian...
Reed - February 23, 2015 11:15 pm
The University of Montana has been in steady decline for over a decade. It has been rotting from the inside. A college should not exist for a team. If teams are to exist at all, their members should be held to a higher standard than the average student. If winning a ball game is more important than educating the next generation then your society is doomed.
The "team" is a liability and always has been. Its a money-making scheme for good-ol-boys paid for by indebted students who are receiving a worthless education. The dropout rate and joblessness rate of actual graduates is abysmal.
On top of all the systemic problems at the U, there was always the notoriously sketchy Missoula PD. The police in Missoula are known nationwide for their misconduct. This is not just an issue relating to this rape accusation. The U has never had a "rape culture" and everyone knows it. The U has a Griz problem and a local-police problem. The Missoula PD just thought they could do what they always have done, which is cover-up for their buddies awhile generating revenue off the student population, which offers an endless stream of minor offenses to profit and expand upon. In this case, they got caught and people noticed. Hilariously few Missoulians "get it" but luckily Krakauer did.
The Missoulian is frequently complicit in this social rot with their inability to deliver hard-hitting reporting that improves the town. They are all-too afraid of Missoula's precious "reputation." Well it looks like Krakauer just flushed that reputation, so you may as well start realtalking before these issues get even worse. New (female) prosecutor won't change much. The problem is in the police and the U. Hopefully, that is exactly what the book is about.
What an idiot. Virtually everything in the letter is incorrect and not supported by fact or anything. That person is a total loser, in my view.
you sound like billy madison or some average junior high school kid with that response.PlayerRep said:getgrizzy said:this response was in the missoulian...
Reed - February 23, 2015 11:15 pm
The University of Montana has been in steady decline for over a decade. It has been rotting from the inside. A college should not exist for a team. If teams are to exist at all, their members should be held to a higher standard than the average student. If winning a ball game is more important than educating the next generation then your society is doomed.
The "team" is a liability and always has been. Its a money-making scheme for good-ol-boys paid for by indebted students who are receiving a worthless education. The dropout rate and joblessness rate of actual graduates is abysmal.
On top of all the systemic problems at the U, there was always the notoriously sketchy Missoula PD. The police in Missoula are known nationwide for their misconduct. This is not just an issue relating to this rape accusation. The U has never had a "rape culture" and everyone knows it. The U has a Griz problem and a local-police problem. The Missoula PD just thought they could do what they always have done, which is cover-up for their buddies awhile generating revenue off the student population, which offers an endless stream of minor offenses to profit and expand upon. In this case, they got caught and people noticed. Hilariously few Missoulians "get it" but luckily Krakauer did.
The Missoulian is frequently complicit in this social rot with their inability to deliver hard-hitting reporting that improves the town. They are all-too afraid of Missoula's precious "reputation." Well it looks like Krakauer just flushed that reputation, so you may as well start realtalking before these issues get even worse. New (female) prosecutor won't change much. The problem is in the police and the U. Hopefully, that is exactly what the book is about.
What an idiot. Virtually everything in the letter is incorrect and not supported by fact or anything. That person is a total loser, in my view.