• Hi Guest, want to participate in the discussions, keep track of read/unread posts access private forums and more? Create your free account and increase the benefits of your eGriz.com experience today!

What am I missing with Ah Yat?

This is a coaching staff who is notorious - for 22+ years now - to NEVER want to put the ball in a freshman / RS freshman's hands unless they see them as a freak of nature with talent. Furthermore they've always felt this way about the QB. Only twice, when forced only by injury, did they trust an RS Frosh to be QB. Justin Hartman for one game against Idaho, and Cole Bergquist in 2005 when Jason Washington got hurt. That was is. Usually, when even faced with the probability of having an RS Soph QB, they'd make sure to bring in a transfer to compete and (usually) win the job. That has been their MO forever.

Until last year & this year. Then suddenly they give Ah Yat some games and some meaningful reps. They proceed forward to give him the chance to actually win the job and start the season with him in at QB1. Even after Fife played lights out for a few games, they went back to the rotation in hopes have Ah Yat rise up and take the job.

That tells me that either this staff, who is generally a little stubborn in their ways, had suddenly decided to adapt to the way they do things with young QBs, or they see something in Ah Yat that they've never seen in other young QBs.

Ah Yat is a very good athlete too, he can be a very well rounded QB if he can improve on vision / reads and probably work on his outward leadership of others as well.

We've seen some great throws from him and some good running too.

I think he's the future, Fife is the right now.
...or, they see everything none of us see everyday in meetings and practice. This is what everyone posting misses. Attitude, effort, preparation, work ethic, leadership in the meeting rooms, class attendance...

They see things we cannot and those things lead them to decisions that can be hard for us to understand...
 
...or, they see everything none of us see everyday in meetings and practice. This is what everyone posting misses. Attitude, effort, preparation, work ethic, leadership in the meeting rooms, class attendance...

They see things we cannot and those things lead them to decisions that can be hard for us to understand...
Isn’t the bottom line winning? The best athlete should play before the favored athlete.
 
It's almost like you don't have a brain. People's decisions indicate their intentions. Fife was far superior to AY all year, yet Bobby played the inferior player.
Bobby would never forego winning. You can criticize his decision making on the QB position, but he believes that the team can win with KAY. You suggesting that he doesn't care about winning ranks right up there with all the other drivel you post.
 
It is more crazy that you don't think he values winning. But if I consider the source, maybe not so much.
I know it's crazy that he would leave a quarterback in the game who had 34 yards passing through nearly two quarters against the worst defense in FCS. It kind of looks like a decision from someone not interested in winning.
 
Back
Top