No one said Weir was too small, just that the Cat o-line is undersized, actually small.Wait, but I thought Tommy wasn't a true QB, and I thought Marcus was too small to be a good OL? lol
Question.. What is considered "Small" and what isn't. Are we going just weight? Weight and Height? Let's put a number to it... Is small anyone under 6'4? and is small 290 and under? Just want to get a handle on what is considered "Small".No one said Weir was too small, just that the Cat o-line is undersized, actually small.
UNM has 14 o-lineman above 300.
I thought you said that Davis was all-world, and that no UM rb would be in top 6 at MSU? How is Gillman getting all these awards?
Who cares? I'll take a tough, smart, physical 270lb O Lineman every day. Guarantee the Cats have a better OL than UNM.No one said Weir was too small, just that the Cat o-line is undersized, actually small.
UNM has 14 o-lineman above 300.
I thought you said that Davis was all-world, and that no UM rb would be in top 6 at MSU? How is Gillman getting all these awards?
Small is the Cat’s starting line. I assume you can look up their weight and height.Question.. What is considered "Small" and what isn't. Are we going just weight? Weight and Height? Let's put a number to it... Is small anyone under 6'4? and is small 290 and under? Just want to get a handle on what is considered "Small".
Why are you so defensive? I said the Cat o-line is small. They are. It’s not disputable. I said nothing else about them.Who cares? I'll take a tough, smart, physical 270lb O Lineman every day. Guarantee the Cats have a better OL than UNM.
No, I didn't do much research on them because knowing the heights and weights for the OL tells you absolutely nothing about how good they are. I remember a few years ago I was concerned about the Cats going up against a team that had MONSTER sized O and D Lines. I thought we might get pushed around due to how much bigger they were on both lines. Nope, Cats pushed them around all game and crushed them.Why are you so defensive? I said the Cat o-line is small. They are. It’s not disputable. I said nothing else about them.
Tell us about the UNM o-line. I assume you did some research? What are their sizes? Who are their starters?
I assume UNM will beat the Cats.
If you don’t know anything about NM o-line, how can you guarantee Cat o-line is better?No, I didn't do much research on them because knowing the heights and weights for the OL tells you absolutely nothing about how good they are. I remember a few years ago I was concerned about the Cats going up against a team that had MONSTER sized O and D Lines. I thought we might get pushed around due to how much bigger they were on both lines. Nope, Cats pushed them around all game and crushed them.
If you think UNM will beat the Cats you should put some $$ down on that. Vegas odds show Cats as favorites by 7.5 points.
I am simply asking what is considered small. Is it anyone under 6'4? Is it anyone under 300 pounds? Do you need to be over 6'4" and over 300 pounds to not be small? I didn't say the Cats are Big, I just asked what the parameters are.Small is the Cat’s starting line. I assume you can look up their weight and height.
Does every freaking thread have to devolve into an argument about the Cats? MOST OF US DON'T CARE SO PLEASE JUST SHUT
Because Vigen knows what he's doing, especially with the OL, and the Cats have had one of the best O Lines in the country every year since he's been here. 2024 will be no different. I'm sure UNM will have some good or great players on the OL, but it's probably going to take them some time to gel, if they ever do.If you don’t know anything about NM o-line, how can you guarantee Cat o-line is better?
I saw the Cat o-line in one game in person last season. 1-14 in 3d/4th down conversions. The Cat o-line got crushed by the Griz. Not a top o-lineman in that game.Because Vigen knows what he's doing, especially with the OL, and the Cats have had one of the best O Lines in the country every year since he's been here. 2024 will be no different. I'm sure UNM will have some good or great players on the OL, but it's probably going to take them some time to gel, if they ever do.
Here's the size of the UNM o-line from their spring ball two-deep. These guys are not small like the Cats. All transfers. 2 seniors and 3 juniors. 7 of the top 10 were transfers. I don't know if they got any late transfers after spring ball.I am simply asking what is considered small. Is it anyone under 6'4? Is it anyone under 300 pounds? Do you need to be over 6'4" and over 300 pounds to not be small? I didn't say the Cats are Big, I just asked what the parameters are.
I didn't ask about UNM, I asked what is considered small. That is all.Here's the size of the UNM o-line from their spring ball two-deep. These guys are not small like the Cats. All transfers. 2 seniors and 3 juniors. 7 of the top 10 were transfers. I don't know if they got any late transfers after spring ball.
6'3", 315, Campbell/UCLA, starter at Campbell last season (where the new UNM o-line coach was)
6'6", 332, Florida Atlantic
6'3", 315, Grambling
6'4", 310, Texas A&M-Commerce
6'2", 303, East Carolina
The d-line are all senior transfers.
6'3", 292, Old Dominion
6'1", 270, USC - "Played in 35 games over a five-year career at USC, recording 32 tackles, 6.5 TFLs and QB Hurry … played in nine games as a senior with 12 tackles, 5.0 TFLs for 20 yads and 1.5 sacks for 12 yards … recorded 14 tackles with 1.5 TFLs as he played in all 13 games for USC in 2022"
6'5", 255, Weber St
I happen to notice this transfer corner: "San Diego State: Played in 25 games with eight starts in 2021 and 2022 before redshirting in 2023 … was named preseason All-MW by Athlon in 2022 and he recorded 36 tackles 1.5 for loss, forced fumble, an interception, and three pass breakups … as a true freshman had 15 tackles (10 solo), 0.5 tackles for loss, an interception, a fumble recovery and two pass breakups and started the opener, a first for an SDSU corner since 2009."
I would assume below the average. But I have zero idea if the bubs OL is small, because I flat out don't give a flying fukc.I didn't ask about UNM, I asked what is considered small. That is all.
Small is what the Cat o-line is. Read their sizes.I didn't ask about UNM, I asked what is considered small. That is all.
Cool. Well then UNM should dominate both lines and crush the Cats with all that size. I know you've already stated you assume UNM will win. We'll see how she goes.Here's the size of the UNM o-line from their spring ball two-deep. These guys are not small like the Cats. All transfers. 2 seniors and 3 juniors. 7 of the top 10 were transfers. I don't know if they got any late transfers after spring ball.
6'3", 315, Campbell/UCLA, starter at Campbell last season (where the new UNM o-line coach was)
6'6", 332, Florida Atlantic
6'3", 315, Grambling
6'4", 310, Texas A&M-Commerce
6'2", 303, East Carolina
The d-line are all senior transfers.
6'3", 292, Old Dominion
6'1", 270, USC - "Played in 35 games over a five-year career at USC, recording 32 tackles, 6.5 TFLs and QB Hurry … played in nine games as a senior with 12 tackles, 5.0 TFLs for 20 yads and 1.5 sacks for 12 yards … recorded 14 tackles with 1.5 TFLs as he played in all 13 games for USC in 2022"
6'5", 255, Weber St
I happen to notice this transfer corner: "San Diego State: Played in 25 games with eight starts in 2021 and 2022 before redshirting in 2023 … was named preseason All-MW by Athlon in 2022 and he recorded 36 tackles 1.5 for loss, forced fumble, an interception, and three pass breakups … as a true freshman had 15 tackles (10 solo), 0.5 tackles for loss, an interception, a fumble recovery and two pass breakups and started the opener, a first for an SDSU corner since 2009."