You people are having so much fun, I hope you don’t mind if I toss in some football data … as most of you know, I’m a numbers guy.
Becton reminds me of Jay Walker (ESPN announcer), the way he rhapsodizes over the wonders of HBCU football. Neither of them seem to understand (don’t want to, I suppose) that these teams are not competitive at the FCS level. Sure, Becton throws out some high NCAA rankings for Florida A&M (FAMU) in various team categories, including several defensive stats. But it’s not that difficult to show good results when your competition is crap. And most of the SWAC and MEAC teams are crap.
Numbers for conference strength (from Sagarin, but others are basically the same): MEAC = 34.28 (#26). SWAC-EAST = 33.41 (#27). SWAC-WEST = 31.31 (#28). Only the sad Northeast Conference and Pioneer League are weaker. For comparison, MVFC = 55.72 (#16, tops among 1-AA). BSC = 52.50 (#17).
Currently, there are eighteen teams in the two HBCU conference, six in the MEAC and twelve in the two-division SWAC. With that many teams, the members mostly play each other, either as regular conference games or as out-of-conference (OOC) matches.
Still, between 2017 and through 2023, those eighteen teams played 143 games against FCS opponents outside of either HBCU conference. (They also played 115 FBS money games, and 110 against D-II or lower level teams. They got blown out in the money games, but managed to win 85% against the non-D-I opponents.) Most of the FCS opponents were lower tier: Abilene Christian, Nichols, McNeese, Georgetown, Hampton, Wagner. etc. Yet even with that advantage, the HBCU teams won less than a quarter of those games: 34-109 (23.8%).
The Southern Conference seemed like it would make a good comparison because those nine teams play many OOC games at the FCS level. They are also high-middle in strength (Sagarin #20). SoCon teams went 61-45 (57.5%) against those FCS opponents. (That would look even better if I excluded several losses in the playoffs, including Montana’s win this year over Furman.)
Bottom line: The MEAC/SWAC teams mostly lose when they venture out of their HBCU enclave to play other FCS opponents. Since they now point toward the post-season Celebration Bowl, they need at least one “extra” good team to get an invite to the FCS playoffs. That’s rare, but it does happen. This year, NC Central got pummeled by Richmond, 49-27. It’s been a quarter century since one of these teams has won an FCS playoff game (FAMU in 1999).
For Becton to trot out statistics compiled against mostly HBCU opponents is either monumentally stupid or laughably biased. (FWIW: Between them, the two conferences played just 25 games this year against FCS opponents outside the HBCU … they were 9-16.)