PlayerRep said:
To me, this were huge missed opportunities. Judged today, they were total screwups.
I'd put these 2 CDC problems, along with the CDC testing issue, in my Top 5 for screwups and missed opportunities. Masks would be in my Top 5. So would generally not pushing along manufacturing of PPE a bit faster, or much faster.
I would put Trump messaging in another category by itself. It wasn't good, but it's hard for me to rate that because I'm not sure who was really listening to him and taking action based on what he said. My view is that the Dems and the press used his messaging against him and kept shouting all the way, but I don't see how his messaging killed anyone in an elder care home. I suppose one could argue that his messaging to downplay the virus caused some elder care home employees not to be careful enough and they got covid and infected older people at work. However, I'm not so sure that elder care home workers tended to be people following Trump, and there were lots of elder care home precautions put in place fairly quickly.
Sending older covid patients back to elder care homes was a huge goof up, but I put it in a category by itself, and that was all over the various governors.
Vaccine development was a huge positive. Extra beds in places like NY were positive, even though probably not necessary. Same with more production of ventilators. Closing down travel from China early. Too bad travel from Europe and other places wasn't restricted sooner, but that was a tough one. The CDC screwups potentially could have gotten the US to closing down European travel earlier.
After Trump lost and now that Biden is in charge, has caused the media and Dems to calm down and keep pointing fingers at every opportunity.
yes, vaccine development was phenomenal. distribution of the vaccine, and prioritization of non 1a or 1b tier individuals by many institutions was unforgivable. i read some hospital in georgia was removed from the places receiving vaccine for six months, because they did something similar to what apparently happened in billings - giving the vaccine to administrators and other lower risk individuals. harvard and many other institutions, including the very high-profile scripps hospitals in socal, should also receive some sort of penalty, but they are too rich, powerful, and connected to the hhs. two of the nih institute directors i know, including one who's lab i was sort-of in as a postdoc (i conducted research at two institutes, it's a long story), are scripps guys. one got his girlfriend a huge lab, with basically blank-check funding, when he took the nih position.
sorry, the above is a long ramble, because the issue pisses me off, but the point i want to make is that it is private industry research and development companies, where one's findings have to be real and of value to somebody, that have made the best vaccines - pfizer and moderna. if only they could also be in charge of distribution... here's an interesting read, sort of, until plotkin starts 'humble bragging': https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2021/01/27/expert-covid-vaccine/?arc404=true