Lamson > Ay Yat

[CDAGRIZ]

Im pretty sure Lamson broke the conference season completion percentage record by a couple percentage points.

While completion percentage for Bobcat QBs is largely a political statistic, an argument could be made that Lamson is the best QB in BSC history.

 

[ilovethecats]

Both are great and will both have excellent seasons. Both fanbases should be very happy with what they deliver this coming season. Really a dumb argument

 

[uofmman1122]

Both are great and will both have excellent seasons. Both fanbases should be very happy with what they deliver this coming season. Really a dumb argument

Are you new here?

 

[alabamagrizzly]

While completion percentage for Bobcat QBs is largely a political statistic, an argument could be made that Lamson is the best QB in BSC history.

 

[SoldierGriz]

Evidence? These selections are pretty much always subjective and political. As for this selection not being close, that's total BS. An argument can easily be made for Lamson considering his numbers and results.

More assertions with no evidence.

 

[SoldierGriz]

I never said he was undeserving as I said in my actual post. I was making a general comment about these all conference selections that said it was generally a bad method for determining who is actually the better player. Retard.

What's your method shitbag?

 

[SoldierGriz]

While completion percentage for Bobcat QBs is largely a political statistic, an argument could be made that Lamson is the best QB in BSC history.

Completely subjective and political.

I'm told there are better methods to determine post-season accolades.

 

[SoldierGriz]

Not sure how it is at all programs, but I have had one head coach tell me he never voted for anything...he had someone in the athletic program do all of his ballots. He thought they were a waste of time.

Which coach?

 

[mthoopsfan]

Completely subjective and political.

I'm told there are better methods to determine post-season accolades.

Lamson was able to get up to 2d team because the Cats won conference. Otherwise he would have been below that. Yes, politics got him there. Same way with Brott. Lamson had games where he threw only 10 and 12 passes, I believe.

 

[alabamagrizzly]

Lamson...had games where he threw only 10 and 12 passes, I believe.

You would be wrong. Or did you mean Jameson when I'm assuming you meant Lamson.

 

[SoldierGriz]

Lamson was able to get up to 2d team because the Cats won conference. Otherwise he would have been below that. Yes, politics got him there. Same way with Brott. Jameson had games where he threw only 10 and 12 passes, I believe.

I honestly don't know what "politics" means in this context.

I know winning teams produce more all conference selections...but, I don't think that's politics...I think it is common sense.

 

[Skookum-Jim]

Completely subjective and political.

I'm told there are better methods to determine post-season accolades.

Yea like results.
oh did I forget to thank you for your service? Tell us one more time what a super trooper you are.

 

[CDAGRIZ]

I honestly don't know what "politics" means in this context.

I know winning teams produce more all conference selections...but, I don't think that's politics...I think it is common sense.

Wins are political statistics in the Bobcat context, much like losses in the Griz context. Virtually meaningless to the informed follower.

 

[tourist]

My neighbor and I had this debate yesterday. The numbers don’t stack up to support his argument. Lamson is very good, but is he really better than Ah Yat? I don’t think he is. Two different systems and Ah Yat was very disciplined with not trying to do too much last year with his feet. Lamson was 15th in the conference for rushing yards and the Cats had three players in the top 15. Lamson also had a better defensive squad to help him out in my opinion. He is poised and a good leader. So is Ah Yat and this is probably the year he really comes into his own. BSC stats show two pretty evenly matched QB’s. Interceptions were understandably higher for Ah Yat given he aired quite a bit more. 470 attempts vs. 356. Lamson has the hardware and Ah Yat has plenty of motivation. Going to be great battles to watch this season.

Just wondering, did your neighbor move next to you, or did you move next to him?

 

[Bobcat99]

Lamson was able to get up to 2d team because the Cats won conference. Otherwise he would have been below that. Yes, politics got him there. Same way with Brott. Lamson had games where he threw only 10 and 12 passes, I believe.

You would be wrong on your last sentence. Better reboot the AI machine.

In all seriousness, if you’re bothered by lack of passes attempted, are you suggesting that it should be a purely statistical award? I’m curious what you actually think.

 

[HelenaHandBasket]

Sounds like Lamson needed a better team of lobbyists.

 

[indiancoyote]

Ah Yat is better at throwing the ball, Lamson is better at running. Therefore Ah Yat is the superior QB

Lamson is better at winning championships. Therefore, he is superior.

 

[HelenaHandBasket]

Lamson is better at winning championships. Therefore, he is superior.

Trent Dilfer in chat everyone.

 

[indiancoyote]

Trent Dilfer in chat everyone.

You probably think Kerry Collins is better than Trent Dilfer, too.

 

[HelenaHandBasket]

You probably think Kerry Collins is better than Trent Dilfer, too.

Great one. You got me. I will file this under "guy absurdly changes subject based on nothing but hurt feelers".