NativeGriz said:
I have always wondered if the girl in question ever thought it would go this far. I was concerned that her mom being friends with Pat William's wife fanned the fires.
That was part of the problem for the prosecution, the fact that her own Mother didn't believe her. That, alone, was astonishing and suggestive that a lot of "history" and "unresolved" attitudes were bubbling beneath the surface here.
I understand that a week before trial, she was wanting "out," and Fred had to make what would have been in most cases a "plea deal" offer that was pretty inviting.
When a case falls apart during the prosecution phase, and especially upon the unconvincing testimony of the alleged victim, "Houston, we have a problem." And the problem was the alleged victim.
And when I say "unconvincing" I mean that this was not the testimony of someone who had been victimized, humiliated, overwhelmed and raped. It came across in many ways as the opposite: manipulative, evasive, and even vindictive. She was the least sympathetic accusing witness in this kind of case I have ever seen.
The testimony resonated with the attitude "I shouldn't have to be here," and that "I didn't get what I wanted out of any of this." The unspoken effect of body posture and attitude on the jury was of someone who felt "entitled" to "get her way" and that she was offended by the fact that she
didn't "get her way." This should have all been taken care of for her, and she resented having to actually "do something" to "get" JJ.
That was the reason her Mom doubted her: this was no "shrinking violet" that was ever passive about anything. She was very experienced with "aggressive boys," and her history was that of going out of her way to cultivate these relationships, sometimes quite aggressively herself. She's a smart girl; nobody manipulates
her. Nobody takes advantage of
her. And the Jury caught that. But she still thought she was smarter than everybody else and couldn't hide that conceit. It was a hubris that was all too evident during her testimony.
That was the whole "Forester's Ball" episode in a nutshell: she was not going to be
denied. Had the Jury been allowed to hear about the Forester's Ball episode the night before, they would have been back in about 30 minutes.