Is Simis better than Prokop?

[AZGrizFan]

Yes. Prokupp overthrows more receivers downfield than he hits. He's a good runner and a good athlete, but he's not a great QB.

I'm certainly NOT saying Semi didn't have a nice game, a great game even, I'm saying he hasn't done anything long enough to be compared to anyone...period.

BTW: you stand alone in your evaluation of Prukop. 175.7% completion % 2062 total yards accounted for and 18 TD's against 4 Int's... he's only HALFway done this year. Not that the facts matter to you... you live in CdA!

No one in football, at any level, will ever be as good as Prokop, past, present, or future. For every 4 passes he attempts he completes 7!

Truly, you have a dizzying intellect! :lol: :lol:

 

[UMGriz75]

BTW: you stand alone in your evaluation of Prukop. 175.7% completion %

Well, I'm impressed, that's for sure.

 

[EverettGriz]

Not that the facts matter to you..

Hmm, it appears the facts may not matter much to you as well. :lol:

 

[blondeh2o]

BTW: you stand alone in your evaluation of Prukop. 175.7% completion %

Well, I'm impressed, that's for sure.

Maths is hard.

 

[grizpack]

Yes. Prokupp overthrows more receivers downfield than he hits. He's a good runner and a good athlete, but he's not a great QB.

I'm certainly NOT saying Semi didn't have a nice game, a great game even, I'm saying he hasn't done anything long enough to be compared to anyone...period.

BTW: you stand alone in your evaluation of Prukop. 175.7% completion % 2062 total yards accounted for and 18 TD's against 4 Int's... he's only HALFway done this year. Not that the facts matter to you... you live in CdA!

I didn't realize he is that good. In fact, I don't think there will ever be a QB in the entire future of football that will beat that completion percentage!!! That is outstanding!!! How do they ever lose????

However, going back to the question in the title... No.

 

[nzone]

No Simis is not better than prukop. Is he as good? Let's see how things unfold the young man but he plays inspired football and has a lot of confidence. Not to mention he gets to throw to some of the best wide receivers in the country. If he can get the necessary time to throw he will turn a lot of heads.

 

[CDAGRIZ]

Yeah, I still think Precum is more of a runner, but I'm fine if Cat fans don't think so. They also thought McGhee was really good.

 

[Silvertip]

Grow up GB: Purposeless graphics that don't move the narrative are nothing more than an adolescent cyber coloring book and crayons.

 

[ABQCat]

Hoy is our best QB by far.

 

[snap]

I'd say that Simis is the superior overall quarterback. He's more accurate, puts a nice touch on the ball and is more intelligent with his decision making. Furthermore, he's respected by the team. I've heard that Purvcop is on the verge of losing his teammates because of his 'me first' attitude.

 

[BWahlberg]

Why stop at comparison to Prukop? Shouldn't we be debating why Simis is better than Dave Dickenson? I mean... this is egriz after all....

 

[CDAGRIZ]

I heard the same. Plodcrap needs to have the team over for summer salad and a Sex and the City marathon.

 

[George Ferguson]

Prukop is now tied with Cooper Kupp as the front-runner for the Peyton Award. With Vlad Lee and Wentz both going down, it's a two-man race between those two now.

 

[snap]

Prukop is now tied with Cooper Kupp as the front-runner for the Peyton Award. With Vlad Lee and Wentz both going down, it's a two-man race between those two now.

That's a good one.

 

[MsMaroon]

Prukop is now tied with Cooper Kupp as the front-runner for the Peyton Award. With Vlad Lee and Wentz both going down, it's a two-man race between those two now.

Even if both stay on pace, I would bet that Cooper Kupp wins it hands down.

 

[snap]

I heard the same. Plodcrap needs to have the team over for summer salad and a Sex and the City marathon.

Add in a pony keg of Michelob Ultra and you've summed Bozeman up perfectly.

 

[SoldierGriz]

Prukop is now tied with Cooper Kupp as the front-runner for the Peyton Award. With Vlad Lee and Wentz both going down, it's a two-man race between those two now.

Even if both stay on pace, I would bet that Cooper Kupp wins it hands down.

This.is.not.even.close. Tied for first place...Kupp is the best player in the FCS by margins that are difficult to describe.

 

[UMGriz75]

Why stop at comparison to Prukop? Shouldn't we be debating why Simis is better than Dave Dickenson? I mean... this is egriz after all....

Nice article on Dave Dickenson from last year.

http://www.bigskyconf.com/news/2014/6/19/FB_0619144751.aspx

He too was an "untested sophomore quarterback" who blew the game away when put in during the second half against SD State. "Down 39-7 with 3:18 remaining in the third quarter, the comeback began. Less than six minutes of game time later, Montana led 39-38."

http://www.bigskyconf.com/news/2013/11/6/FB_1106131547.aspx

 

[IHateRobPhenicie]

No

 

[AZGrizFan]

Prukop is now tied with Cooper Kupp as the front-runner for the Peyton Award. With Vlad Lee and Wentz both going down, it's a two-man race between those two now.

Even if both stay on pace, I would bet that Cooper Kupp wins it hands down.

This.is.not.even.close. Tied for first place...Kupp is the best player in the FCS by margins that are difficult to describe.

Agreed. But what happened to Vlad the Impaler?