• Hi Guest, want to participate in the discussions, keep track of read/unread posts access private forums and more? Create your free account and increase the benefits of your eGriz.com experience today!

Fife in the portal

HelenaHandBasket said:
I am still laughing because your own words tell us that you are outraged because they played one bad QB instead of another bad QB. And you still haven't provided any actual evidence that is was bias and favoritism.
Click to expand...
Where was the bad QB quantified in this discussion. HHB are you making stuff up again?
 
HelenaHandBasket said:
And some fumbles. Bottom line, they were both not good. The SDSU game wasn't going to end differently if Fife played. But you be you and beat the "Ah Yat only played because of favoritism" drum from here to eternity. They played Ah Yat because they believed he was the best option. Or are you one of these guys suggesting that Bobby doesn't care about winning?
Click to expand...
Bobby brought up his feelings before this year when it came to decisions, and with the clear different treatment of AhYat and a Fife over the course of the season despite every statistic proving otherwise it doesn't seem to far fetched. And I think he cares about winning, but he also will do whatever he wants despite it not being the best option, literally the 2nd year in a row we've had QB controversy.
 
Ut-Grizfan said:
Like hell you aren't, his overall stats over the last 4 games he played in:

51/93 593 Yards 4TDs 1Int

Not world beating by any means but not at all God awful like you're claiming. AhYat literally had as many interceptions vs SDSU that Fife had all season
Click to expand...
2 fumbles that kept opponent in playoff game though. Watching Ah Yat play you can't help but be excited about his potential. He made some plays and made some mistakes. Fife played well in some games but after all these years he's been playing we may have seen his ceiling. SDSU has a comparable defense to the Cats and Fife didn't play well at all vs Cats. And then he's putting out crap on social media and letting everyone know he's out the door. It was the right thing to let Ah Yat start and play through it. He is going to be a very good QB.
 
Ut-Grizfan said:
I never said he played perfectly, but did he play better then AhYat? 100%. Alot of putting words in my mouth going on.
Click to expand...
I saw more good things yesterday from Keali'i than I saw from Logan in the games against MSU and TSU.

And so did the coaches, which is why he didn't play.
 
Ut-Grizfan said:
Bobby brought up his feelings before this year when it came to decisions, and with the clear different treatment of AhYat and a Fife over the course of the season despite every statistic proving otherwise it doesn't seem to far fetched. And I think he cares about winning, but he also will do whatever he wants despite it not being the beat option, literally the 2nd year in a row we've had QB controversy.
Click to expand...
There are so many coaches that will make decisions on a gut feeling. I also say that we need to agree to disagree that Fife was a better option, dude has been ass the last 4 weeks. Your argument of favoritism has been nothing more than conjecture.
 
UncleRico said:
2 fumbles that kept opponent in playoff game though. Watching Ah Yat play you can't help but be excited about his potential. He made some plays and made some mistakes. Fife played well in some games but after all these years he's been playing we may have seen his ceiling. SDSU has a comparable defense to the Cats and Fife didn't play well at all vs Cats. And then he's putting out crap on social media and letting everyone know he's out the door. It was the right thing to let Ah Yat start and play through it. He is going to be a very good QB.
Click to expand...
I hope this is the case and believe me I WANT to be proven wrong. However AhYat has done little and the way the coaching staff handled things this season to give me hope for either.
 
uofmman1122 said:
I'm not even trying to say that Ah Yat played amazing here. He clearly made dumb mistakes and it cost us a lot.

But people have this version of Logan Fife they keep pointing to that has not existed for several weeks despite ample opportunity to be that guy.
Click to expand...
And then marry that to supposition, conjecture and a conspiracy story to conclude that Bobby would rather forgo winning football games just to play a legacy player he favors.
 
uofmman1122 said:
I saw more good things yesterday from Keali'i than I saw from Logan in the games against MSU and TSU.

And so did the coaches, which is why he didn't play.
Click to expand...
Fife messed up against Davis with the INT: Gets pulled

Fife Fumbles vs TSU: Gets pulled

AhYat can't lead offense to score vs PSU, throws an INT: Stays in game until injured

AhYat multiple turnovers and 3 and outs vs SDSU: Allowed to stay in game

Seems pretty clear to me that they were both treated differently this season or held to different standards, and these are just a few examples.
 
Shame on some of you fuckfaces. Trying to foment a pissing match between Ah Yat and Fife.

Bad fucking douchebag form.
 
Ut-Grizfan said:
Fife messed up against Davis with the INT: Gets pulled

Fife Fumbles vs TSU: Gets pulled

AhYat can't lead offense to score vs PSU: stays in game until injured

AhYat multiple turnovers and 3 and outs vs SDSU: Allowed to stay in game

Seems pretty clear to me that they were both treated differently this season or held to different standards, and these are just a few examples.
Click to expand...
Ah yat was in the first half of the game against PSU because Logan was an idiot and posted shit on social media.

Ah Yat stayed in against SDSU because I'm pretty sure the staff knew Logan was leaving, and there's no point bringing him in when he showed he couldn't do a good job against worse defenses.

This is not some conspiracy, dude.
 
uofmman1122 said:
Ah yat was in the first half of the game against PSU because Logan was an idiot and posted shit on social media.

Ah Yat stayed in against SDSU because I'm pretty sure the staff knew Logan was leaving, and there's no point bringing him in when he showed he couldn't do a good job against worse defenses.

This is not some conspiracy, dude.
Click to expand...
So you're saying the only reason Fife didn't play against PSU was because of his X post? He literally only got into the game after AhYat got hurt, if he doesn't I believe Fife isn't allowed to play and good chance we lose.

And against SDSU you're telling me being down 21-3 and being unable to generate any kind of offense with multiple 3 and outs and an interception in the playoffs the coaching staff didn't want to change anything up that could potentially give us a spark? Seems to me like pretty awful coaching, or personal feelings were more important then winning. If Fife had that performance in the first half garunteed he gets pulled for AhYat, history proves it.
 
uofmman1122 said:
His numbers against SDSU (a much harder defense) in one game were better than Fife's numbers in the 2 previous games combined.

QBCompAtt%YardsTDINT/FumbSacksRush ydsRush TD
Fife295652%214024520
Ah Yat193259%231223250
Click to expand...
What were his numbers the first three quarters, before SDSU went prevent and put in their 2’s and 3’s?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Back
Top