HelenaHandBasket
Well-known member
The game of pros and cons.Sure. I would also get not wanting to hand the reins to a guy that is unproven as anything other than a position coach
The game of pros and cons.Sure. I would also get not wanting to hand the reins to a guy that is unproven as anything other than a position coach
Wait… this means “Bobby Ball” is NEVER going away!Montana is "Bobby U"
Yes, Choate was a great recruiter, visionary, motivator. Brought some dudes to MSU. Won a lot of games, but fell short in getting his team to the Championship. Not sure he is a great head coach. See, his record at Nevada. And I know its difficult to win at Nevada, but they are at the bottom of the MWC.Ok went to UM Western and is from Northern Idaho. Had 3 years experience establishing recruiting pipelines at the likes of Billings West as MSU’s head coach is the part of his resume that I would be the most interested in.
We’re playing a game of “stop gap” measuresThe game of pros and cons.
I am not sure how Kennedy will do, but I think it was the best move for the upcoming season. May just delay the inevitable of the roster exodus though, but worth that gamble with the guys coming back.We’re playing a game of “stop gap” measures
I don't see how any of those guys are a more proven commodity than just giving Coach Kennedy a chance.Tony Anesse
Andy Thompson
Several OC’s or DC’s in the mvfc and BSC
Ty Gregorak
The timing was actually best for the roster though. If he had announced this before the portal window opened we would have seen half the team leave. Maybe more. Now it's too late in the year for players to go somewhere new.I really don't know how I feel about this, but I do think this is going to only go 1 of 2 ways. He's going to have to perform otherwise this very much could be a one and done type of year for him, I really don't like the timing Hauk chose.
I am not sure that is accurate.The timing was actually best for the roster though. If he had announced this before the portal window opened we would have seen half the team leave. Maybe more. Now it's too late in the year for players to go somewhere new.
My understanding is when a team loses a coach they ALL have a window to leave, I'm hoping they talked to the team before this to encourage everyone to stay but they are all now able to enter the portal. Hopefully with it being so late it will prevent a mass exodus.The timing was actually best for the roster though. If he had announced this before the portal window opened we would have seen half the team leave. Maybe more. Now it's too late in the year for players to go somewhere new.
Andy Thompson is a good coordinator. Not sure he was great as the head dude in his short tenure. Gregorak is a used car salesman. Annesse is successful for key reasons which won’t work here and brings both baggage and an attitude that could take us back 15 years.Tony Anesse
Andy Thompson
Several OC’s or DC’s in the mvfc and BSC
Ty Gregorak
No it isn’t. Montana is a FCS school and not Indiana. Good program, yes, but in the B league of college football.That’s to dumb to warrant a response
Thats a lot of words to say “I really don’t know dick about coaching or coaches but I’m just gonna throw some shit at the wall and see if something sticks.”Andy Thompson is a good coordinator. Not sure he was great as the head dude in his short tenure. Gregorak is a used car salesman. Annesse is successful for key reasons which won’t work here and brings both baggage and an attitude that could take us back 15 years.
Should we dip back into the d2 ranks or do you really think these coordinators at the upper level will take a huge pay cut to come down to the FCS?
It's the wrong time of the year. Continuity is more important to retain players and recruits. A national search would open the floodgates to the portal.I don't understand why the university doesn't do a national search. I don't get it.
When was the last time Gregorak coached? How long did Andy Thompson remain a head coach at a Big Sky Conference school and what was his overall record.Thats a lot of words to say “I really don’t know dick about coaching or coaches but I’m just gonna throw some shit at the wall and see if something sticks.
If you read eGriz, there's plenty of resistance.It isn’t about “giving the new guy a chance”, it’s about one of the premier programs in the country, once again, taking the path of least resistance.
You'd think weird all right when half the team and recruits abandon ship during this open period.Well how about we open it up and let people apply like other colleges do? That’d be weird, right?
Kennedy looks like an excellent hire with experience in quality programs. In fact, his experience is similar to Bobby’s when he was first hired.I like Kennedy but there is no denying that Choate has more experience and probably better connections within Montana. He successfully turned MSU around and built the foundation that won them the championship this season.
Not sure what that matters. Ty is a good coach, do you think he hasn’t kept up or has somehow forgotten how to coach? Not that it matters, he’s got a good job and I doubt he’d take the pay cut to come back. Andy is also a good coach, I think it’s a proven fact that sac is not a place anybody is going to win consistently but when he gets another shot, which he will, the team that gives it to him is going to be happy with the results.When was the last time Gregorak coached? How long did Andy Thompson remain a head coach at a Big Sky Conference school and what was his overall record.
Ty was an excellent defensive coordinator but I am not sure that he knows as much about offense. He would need a solid OC.Not sure what that matters. Ty is a good coach, do you think he hasn’t kept up or has somehow forgotten how to coach? Not that it matters, he’s got a good job and I doubt he’d take the pay cut to come back. Andy is also a good coach, I think it’s a proven fact that sac is not a place anybody is going to win consistently but when he gets another shot, which he will, the team that gives it to him is going to be happy with the results.
This was MY shortlist not THE shortlist but any AD worth a shit better have one.