Let's do the analysis for the last 10 years:
2014 - Griz 3rd, scats 4th
2015 - Griz 3rd, scats 9th
2016 - Griz 8th, scats 9th
2017 - Griz 6th, scats 7th
2018 - Griz 6th, scats 4th
2019 - Griz 3rd, scats 4th
2020 - Not counting
2021 - Griz 4th, scats 2nd
2022 - Griz 6th, scats 2nd
2023 - Griz 1st, scats 3rd
2024 - Griz 5th, scats 1st
Based on those results, the scats HAVEN'T been having great results for awhile now. For the last 4 years, yes. The last 10, no way. Griz average finish over the last 10 true seasons - 4/5. Scats - 4/5. So the Griz and scats have had similar results.
I think the scats will be good this year. Will they be great, doubful, but that remains to be seen. They lost a lot of talent from last year's squad, especially at one of the most important positions in football - QB. They also lost All-Big Sky Conference players Scottre Humphrey - 1st Team, Conner Moore - 1st Team, Rohan Jones - 1st Team, and Andrew Powdrell - 2nd Team to the transfer portal. Brody Grebe - Big Sky Defensive POY, Marcus Wehr - 1st Team ABSC, Cole Sain - 1st Team ABSC, Rylan Ortt - 1st Team ABSC, and Tommy Mellot - BS Offensive POY graduated and Brody, Marcus, and Tommy went to the NFL. You don't lose that level of talent in one year and replace it with the same level of talent. Where they finish in the BSC standings will come down to how well they replace the huge talent losses, who they play and when they play them, and how healthy they stay. Honestly, with all of the talent they lost off last year's squad, I'm extremely confused why most people are picking them to be as good again this year.