Far be it from me to come to the defense of a 'Scat player, but I just don't get this argument. That may have been his Achilles the past couple years, but not this year. This year he completed 68% of his passes, threw 22 TD's and just 1 (ONE) INT. For comparison, Montana's 2 QB's threw 19 TD's and had 6 INT's. Mellott had the 3rd highest completion percentage and the highest efficiency rating of the top 14 QB's in the league. He had almost 200 more yards on 15 LESS attempts than Fife. Oh, he also rushed for almost 650 yards and 11 more TD's.
To say he can't "win tough games by passing" seems disingenuous or willfully ignorant. If Montana's QB's had those kind of numbers we'd be pissed if they didn't win the WP Award...they don't even have those numbers COMBINED.