The title of this thread is the “relevance” versus possible “irrelevance” of Griz football. Sure, we’d all like to see conference championships, playoff runs, and even a National Championship (and preferably several). But only one team can win the Nattie, so relevance has to be judged on the basis of win and losses. Some people on here are pulling numbers out of their a**es, and eliminating willie-nillie teams that “don’t matter.” One of those numbers is that the Grizz are in the “top 30” of all FCS. On what basis? I assume last year’s NCAA power ranking, which seems reasonable to me.
But that’s just one year. Paytonlives settled on the last seven years as an overall W-L period for a comparison. That encompasses Pflugrads last year on to the present … which works for me. So here we go with some actual numbers. (What a concept!) For my own amusement, I have grayed out teams that “don’t matter” -- to me. That’s mostly based on last year’s power rankings.
FCS W-L Records, 2011-2017
NDSU . . . . . . . . . 97-08 . . 92.4%
Harvard . . . . . . . 57-13 . . 81.4%
SHSU . . . . . . . . . 80-22 . . 78.4%
San Diego . . . . . 63-18 . . 77.8%
Jacksonville St . . 67-21 . . 76.1%
JMU . . . . . . .. . . 67-24 . . 73.6%
NC A&T . . .. . . . 59-22 . . 72.8%
EWU . . . . . . . . . 64-24 . . 72.7%
Beth-Cook . . . . 56-24 . . 70.0%
McNeese . . . . . . 54-25 . . 68.4%
Central Ark. . . . 58-27 . . 68.2%
UNH . . . . . . . . . 62-30 . . 67.4%
SDSU . . . . . . . . 60-31 . . 65.9%
Dartmouth . . . . 46-24 . . 65.7%
Dayton . . .. . . . 51-27 . . 65.4%
Illinois St. . .. . . 56-30 . . 65.1%
Jacksonville . . . 49-27 . . 64.5%
Lehigh . . . .. . . 52-29 . . 64.2%
Drake . . . . . . . 49-28 . . 63.6%
Duquesne . . . . 50-29 . . 63.3%
Wofford . . .. . . 53-32 . . 62.4%
Montana . . . . . 51-31 . . 62.2%
Fordham . . . . . 51-33 . . 60.7%
YSU . . . . . . . . 51-33 . . 60.7%
NAU . . . . . . . . 49-32 . . 60.5%
Samford . . . . . 49-32 . . 60.5%
No. Iowa . .. . . 53-35 . . 60.2%
Richmond . . . . 52-35 . . 59.8%
MSU . . . . . . . . 50-34 . . 59.5%
Towson . . . . . . 51-35 . . 59.3%
Stony Brook . . . 49-34 . . 59.0%
Chattanooga . . 50-35 . . 58.8%
Grambling . . . . 49-35 . . 58.3%
Prairie View . . . 50-36 . . 58.1%
UT-Martin . . . . 46-34 . . 57.5%
Tennessee St. . . 46-34 . . 57.5%
Alabama St. . . . 45-34 . . 57.0%
Villanova . . . . . 47-36 . . 56.6%
Various people might quibble about the teams I have grayed out … and that’s fine. I hesitated about North Carolina A&T, but they had a really good power number, so they "stayed." But I don’t think many would argue about down-grading San Diego, Bethune-Cookman, Dayton and the others.
Anyway, when you do that cut and use the overall 2011-2017 records, there are only twelve teams ahead of the Griz. I’d call that pretty damn good. And pay attention to some teams that we think of as pretty good, but they’re below UM, like: Northern Iowa, Richmond and Villanova. Are those teams irrelevant? I don’t think.