Top Recruiting Priority for 2015

[PlayerRep]

Does Monte not understand that it is not necessary for fans to evaluate and know whether the young qb's have what it takes to take over the position next year? The coaches see the qb's in practice every day, and know their talent level and potential. The main job of the coaches this season is to win football games--not evaluate talent for next year.

Monte seems to think that coaches should not play seniors; they should play only underclassman who will be around next year.

Thank you!!!

I'm not talking about the fans, you meat head. The coaches also need to evaluate these two against real competition, not practice or scrimmages running the third team offense. They don't know anything about whether either of them have the ability to be the man next year, any more than you or I do. When are the going to evaluate them, during their first start next season? Like I said in an earlier post, if they are not better right now than SSH, we are in big trouble next year. He has showed nothing when playing.

Nope, you were not talking about the coaches. You referred to "we" several times. You then asked Brint if he was comfortable with one of the young qb's being the answer next year. No mention of coaches. Brint is a fan, not a coach. Below is your post:

"We know nothing about either Simis or Gus because they have not been given meaningful game-time EXPERIENCE with our first team offense. While experience does not mean they are talented, at least we can see what they are capable of doing now, and be able to project whether either one will be the answer at QB next year. You don't learn that in spring practice or scrimmages. Are you comfortable that one of them will be the answer next season?"

 

[Griz-O-Matic]

Does Monte not understand that it is not necessary for fans to evaluate and know whether the young qb's have what it takes to take over the position next year? The coaches see the qb's in practice every day, and know their talent level and potential. The main job of the coaches this season is to win football games--not evaluate talent for next year.

Monte seems to think that coaches should not play seniors; they should play only underclassman who will be around next year.

Thank you!!!

I'm not talking about the fans, you meat head. The coaches also need to evaluate these two against real competition, not practice or scrimmages running the third team offense. They don't know anything about whether either of them have the ability to be the man next year, any more than you or I do. When are the going to evaluate them, during their first start next season? Like I said in an earlier post, if they are not better right now than SSH, we are in big trouble next year. He has showed nothing when playing.

Nope, you were not talking about the coaches. You referred to "we" several times. You then asked Brint if he was comfortable with one of the young qb's being the answer next year. No mention of coaches. Brint is a fan, not a coach. Below is your post:

"We know nothing about either Simis or Gus because they have not been given meaningful game-time EXPERIENCE with our first team offense. While experience does not mean they are talented, at least we can see what they are capable of doing now, and be able to project whether either one will be the answer at QB next year. You don't learn that in spring practice or scrimmages. Are you comfortable that one of them will be the answer next season?"

Yoe were so fast with your "nope" - you didn't address Monty's concern about the coaches evaluating #'s 3&4.

 

[dupuyer griz]

Does Monte not understand that it is not necessary for fans to evaluate and know whether the young qb's have what it takes to take over the position next year? The coaches see the qb's in practice every day, and know their talent level and potential. The main job of the coaches this season is to win football games--not evaluate talent for next year.

Monte seems to think that coaches should not play seniors; they should play only underclassman who will be around next year.

Thank you!!!

I'm not talking about the fans, you meat head. The coaches also need to evaluate these two against real competition, not practice or scrimmages running the third team offense. They don't know anything about whether either of them have the ability to be the man next year, any more than you or I do. When are the going to evaluate them, during their first start next season? Like I said in an earlier post, if they are not better right now than SSH, we are in big trouble next year. He has showed nothing when playing.

Nope, you were not talking about the coaches. You referred to "we" several times. You then asked Brint if he was comfortable with one of the young qb's being the answer next year. No mention of coaches. Brint is a fan, not a coach. Below is your post:

"We know nothing about either Simis or Gus because they have not been given meaningful game-time EXPERIENCE with our first team offense. While experience does not mean they are talented, at least we can see what they are capable of doing now, and be able to project whether either one will be the answer at QB next year. You don't learn that in spring practice or scrimmages. Are you comfortable that one of them will be the answer next season?"

WE ARE MONTANA

 

[PlayerRep]

Thank you!!!

I'm not talking about the fans, you meat head. The coaches also need to evaluate these two against real competition, not practice or scrimmages running the third team offense. They don't know anything about whether either of them have the ability to be the man next year, any more than you or I do. When are the going to evaluate them, during their first start next season? Like I said in an earlier post, if they are not better right now than SSH, we are in big trouble next year. He has showed nothing when playing.

Nope, you were not talking about the coaches. You referred to "we" several times. You then asked Brint if he was comfortable with one of the young qb's being the answer next year. No mention of coaches. Brint is a fan, not a coach. Below is your post:

"We know nothing about either Simis or Gus because they have not been given meaningful game-time EXPERIENCE with our first team offense. While experience does not mean they are talented, at least we can see what they are capable of doing now, and be able to project whether either one will be the answer at QB next year. You don't learn that in spring practice or scrimmages. Are you comfortable that one of them will be the answer next season?"

Yoe were so fast with your "nope" - you didn't address Monty's concern about the coaches evaluating #'s 3&4.

Nope. First, in the post I addressed, Monte made no mention of coaches. Second, in a prior post, I had already said this: "The coaches see the qb's in practice every day, and know their talent level and potential."

If you're going to post, you need to pay more attention.