Brady certainly didn't have 3 overthrows on longer balls in the first quarter, and I don't think had 3 overthrows in the first Q. Brady throws a nice long ball, and has thrown fairly well long all season, including in the NDSU game. The receivers love to have Brady at qb, in part because Stitt calls for the long ball and Brady throws it. Jones (2d leading UM receiver of all time) quote, when asked about having Brady back: "It makes a big difference. We definitely went deep more, and definitely took advantage of more things...."
I'm sorry, but the qb situation is not a close call. Not even close. It is a huge benefit to the team to have Brady back. No knock on the other qb's. They have strengths and nice potential, and did reasonably well when thrown into the mix.