• Hi Guest, want to participate in the discussions, keep track of read/unread posts access private forums and more? Create your free account and increase the benefits of your eGriz.com experience today!

Majerus abortion rights comment gets Bishops attention

Grizbacker1

Well-known member
I wasn't sure if this should be in Egrizolitics or here. What is your opinion on whether the Bishop should be calling Majerus on the carpet for something I think is a free speech issue?

Majerus abortion rights comment gets St. Louis bishop's attention
Associated Press

January 23, 2008, 12:24 PM ET

ST. LOUIS -- A Roman Catholic archbishop said Tuesday that he will ask officials of Saint Louis University to take "appropriate action" against its basketball coach, who said in a television interview that he supports abortion rights.

St. Louis Archbishop Raymond Burke says he's concerned abortion rights comments made by basketball coach Saint Louis coach Rick Majerus (above) could "lead Catholics astray."
One of the game's winningest coaches, Rick Majerus made the comment at a weekend rally for Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Rodham Clinton.


St. Louis Archbishop Raymond Burke declined to say what the action against Majerus should be, saying that was a decision for the Jesuit university. But he said the coach is a leader and shouldn't support views in opposition to church teaching.

"I'm concerned that a leader at a Catholic university made these comments. It can lead Catholics astray," Burke said by telephone as he attended March for Life anti-abortion events in Washington. "I just believe that it's of the essence for people to understand as a Catholic you just cannot hold these beliefs."

Burke said he will seek to speak with university president Rev. Lawrence Biondi, or a representative, when he returns to St. Louis.

During an interview with KMOV-TV at Saturday's Clinton rally in suburban St. Louis, the first-year Billikens coach identified himself as a Catholic and called himself pro-choice. At first when asked for his views on abortion, he said he didn't want to "go there," but then said he is personally "pro-choice."

Saint Louis University spokesman Clayton Berry said Majerus was at the rally as an individual, not as a representative of the school.

Majerus has one of the best winning percentages among active college basketball coaches with a 432-154 career record. Most of those wins, and a 1998 Final Four appearance, came at the University of Utah, which he left in 2004 due to health concerns.

Before taking the Saint Louis job he worked as an ESPN analyst, and accepted and quickly gave up the coaching job at Southern California.

Burke set off a national debate in 2004 when he said he would deny Holy Communion to John Kerry, then the Democratic presidential nominee, because the Catholic Massachusetts senator supports abortion rights.

The archbishop resigned last year as board chairman for the Cardinal Glennon Children's Foundation because of a benefit-concert appearance by Sheryl Crow, a native Missourian who supports abortion rights and embryonic stem cell research.
 
It was not at a university-sponsored event, and therefore he was not carrying the university's name along with his opinion at that time. Yet this only makes it more difficult to take "appropriate action", and I'm sure many people don't care about this fact and think that he should hold strictly Catholic views even outside the university in his personal life.
 
Drew said:
It was not at a university-sponsored event, and therefore he was not carrying the university's name along with his opinion at that time. Yet this only makes it more difficult to take "appropriate action", and I'm sure many people don't care about this fact and think that he should hold strictly Catholic views even outside the university in his personal life.

That is pretty much my take on it too. I doubt he had to agree to stipulations when he was hired that said he would give up his right to free speech.
 
The way it was explained today (ESPN Radio I think), SLU is no longer a "private" university. They wanted a new stadium, and wanted to use taxpayer money for it. Therefore, they had to change to a public university to use public dollars to build their arena.

If that is the case, SLU can't do much about it.
 
grizpack said:
The way it was explained today (ESPN Radio I think), SLU is no longer a "private" university. They wanted a new stadium, and wanted to use taxpayer money for it. Therefore, they had to change to a public university to use public dollars to build their arena.

If that is the case, SLU can't do much about it.

Either way, I think Majerus has every right to speak his mind on this and any other topic as a private citizen.
 
I agree GB1, but as I married into a very Catholic family, I learned that there are certain areas where other thoughts or beliefs are not tolerated.

I will leave it at that.
 
grizpack said:
I agree GB1, but as I married into a very Catholic family, I learned that there are certain areas where other thoughts or beliefs are not tolerated.

I will leave it at that.

I know precisely where you are coming from. :thumb:
 
Majerus has a great quote in his response:

Auburn commitment visits MSU Majerus at center of controversy
Posted: Friday January 25, 2008 08:17AM ET
St. Louis basketball coach Rick Majerus had no intention of creating such a firestorm when he made an appearance at a Hillary Clinton rally last Saturday night in St. Louis and answered questions regarding his pro-choice, pro-embryonic stem-cell research beliefs for a local TV affiliate. Three days later, Archbishop Raymond Burke of the St. Louis diocese, who is very active in the pro-life movement and recently attended the March for Life conference in Washington, D.C., drew a line in the sand in response. Burke said St. Louis University, which is a university operated by the Jesuit fathers, should discipline Majerus for his comments. He then threatened to deny Majerus, a practicing Catholic, Holy Communion if the coach did not change his positions. "These are my personal views," Majerus said from St. Louis last night. "I'm respectful of the archbishop's position, but it's not going to change my mind. We're given free will and the right to vote for changes. I think religion should be inclusive. I would hope that all people would feel welcome inside a church, and that the church would serve to bring people together, even if they happen to disagree on certain things."
New York Daily News
 

Latest posts

Back
Top