Lamson > Ay Yat

[Allezchat]

What fair share of actually problems has UM had?

It wouldn't be fair to share what um's fair share is.....

 

[mthoopsfan]

It wouldn't be fair to share what um's fair share is.....

You can't name any substantive problems in, say, the last 15 years, I assume. Krakauer's book was largely false on the UM football involvement.

 

[Allezchat]

You can't name any substantive problems in, say, the last 15 years, I assume. Krakauer's book was largely false on the UM football involvement.

You missed the joke....fair to share...fair share of

 

[MTbest]

“2. Pure Arm Talent and Passing Projectability
This is where Ah Yat separates himself in the eyes of NFL personnel.

• Ah Yat: He is a natural, fluid pocket passer with advanced processing skills. He possesses a quick, effortless release and highly impressive intermediate-to-deep ball accuracy. NFL offenses are built on a quarterback's ability to handle high-volume dropbacks, read full-field progressions, and anticipate windows. Ah Yat proved he can carry an entire offense with his arm, delivering high-level touch and velocity on a high volume of throws.
• Lamson: While Lamson’s deep-ball efficiency numbers were staggering, it was heavily aided by Montana State’s dominant, run-heavy option system that freezes safeties and creates massive windows. Lamson has a strong arm, but his mechanics can occasionally get rigid, and he hasn't been asked to carry a high-volume, pass-first pro-style offense the way Ah Yat has.
• Advantage: Ah Yat

3. Modern Mobility and Improvisation​

• Ah Yat: Ah Yat has fantastic pocket presence. He isn't just a runner; he uses his legs to manipulate the pocket, evade the rush, and extend plays while keeping his eyes strictly downfield. This "off-platform" improvisational playmaking is exactly what modern NFL offenses look for.
• Lamson: Lamson is a highly effective, powerful runner on designed plays, but his mobility is more linear and physical.
• Advantage: Ah Yat

The Final Scouting Verdict​

• Keali'i Ah Yat projects as a traditional, high-upside developmental NFL quarterback. He has the pedigree (his father Brian was a legendary Griz QB), the natural arm talent, and the processing ceiling that makes scouts believe he can operate a standard NFL passing game. If he continues to bulk up and cuts down on a few of his sophomore risk-taking interceptions, his ceiling is that of a draftable, multi-year NFL backup with starting potential.
• Justin Lamson projects more as an athletic, versatile weapon. NFL teams love having a backup quarterback who brings a completely different element to the game—think of a Taysom Hill or a Jacoby Brissett type. Lamson’s elite ball security (zero picks in conference play) and short-yardage rushing power make him an intriguing candidate for a team looking for a highly efficient, tough-as-nails depth piece who can execute a specialized package.

If a franchise is looking for a pure quarterback to develop into a future passer, Ah Yat is the guy they turn the tape on first.”

Gemini.

Some very informed analysis, thanks for the effort! Ah Yat size? He's a very good fit in our league, and likely in most D1 levels of play. You indicated, "If he continues to bulk up" will certainly bolster is strengths you point out. NFL wise, he's certainly building on his abilities for quick decision making, defense reads, play options, and of course if he stays healthy. But his size, 6'1 (if he really is?), most obviously, seeing over the line, getting a clear view of the field, and race track speed players/plays, likely going to impact his overall effectiveness. Hell of a Griz player, got the right stuff! Thanks for your post, look forward to more!

 

[mthoopsfan]

You missed the joke....fair to share...fair share of

There was no joke. Feel free to explain the joke.

 

[mthoopsfan]

Some very informed analysis, thanks for the effort! Ah Yat size? He's a very good fit in our league, and likely in most D1 levels of play. You indicated, "If he continues to bulk up" will certainly bolster is strengths you point out. NFL wise, he's certainly building on his abilities for quick decision making, defense reads, play options, and of course if he stays healthy. But his size, 6'1 (if he really is?), most obviously, seeing over the line, getting a clear view of the field, and race track speed players/plays, likely going to impact his overall effectiveness. Hell of a Griz player, got the right stuff! Thanks for your post, look forward to more!

It was Gemini AI, not me.