bigtyme said:
With all due respect, Selvig is not a 5 and should not be played there. He does not like to bang inside and do the normal 5 stuff. He is naturally a perimeter player that has a decent three ball. I never said anything about defense. Ideally he would be played against a 4 or maybe even 5 because he is lengthy and can rebound, but to play there offensively is a mistake. I think we all agree that he is a true 4, but that is not the argument. Just because he is over 7' does not mean he should be a 5. Dirk does not play the 5, nor should Derek as they have very similar games. Just saying.
Talk to most Basketball coaches or scouts and they will tell that what determine a player position is where he defends, so defense is how I judge what position a player plays. Of course how you look at it might be different than how I do. You and I could argue back and forth all we want, but what counts is where Selvig played and where he will play. Talk to Tinkle he will tell you that Selvig and Qvale will be two of the better "big men" in the league next year. In the great fall tribune last month Tinkle hoped that Selvig would be healthy next year so he could start the two at the 4 and 5 spot. Last season I would say Selvig played over 1/2 his minutes at the center, and 1/2 at power forward. I do not remember him playing one minute at the small forward spot. Next year I see him starting at the power forward (barring injury), but I will bet he will play far more minutes at the center spot than the small forward (if he plays any minutes there).
Yes Selvig is a great passer and perimeter shooter, but today a lot of the better power forward have those skills that is why coaches have gone to calling floor positions by numbers because the old position names (power forward, small forward, center shooting guard point guard) are not as accurate. At the four spot Selvig will still get his three point shots, and will still get a few from the 5 spot but he is not a three. Still though we can argue all we want about it but the truth will come out next year.