GrizFan2011 said:bluemarlin2 said:You are right. It was Glenn's fault?catgrizfan said:He got dealt a SHITTY hand and did the best he could. Maybe I missed it but I am pretty sure Mick didn't guarantee anything this season and didn't come out and suck on purpose. Is he the best Griz coach ever? Not even remotely close....but putting the blame solely on Mick is just stupid.
Mick got handed a great team of players. He is not a Head Coach. Never has been.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but out of the 4 QBs we have, two are pro-style types (SSH & Gustafson) and two are spread-option types (TM & AB). If Pflu recruited SSH, what was Pflu thinking, when he was running a s-o offense? I don't know who recruited Gustafson, but same question.becker2117 said:If we had an AVERAGE BSC qb we could have easily won that game today. The problem is SSH is so so so limited that we cant move the ball once the d commits to stop the run....i think this is why our playcalling seems so brutal because they dont really have confidence the ball can be pushed down the field.
Wolfman_Jack said:A major part of the head coach's job is to get kids to focus despite outside distractions, it's a valuable life skill that even average coaches can instill to their players.
This team obviously failed miserably at that task.
And obviously our HC isn't even average as a coach. And you want to give him credit because he wasn't the cause of the distractions, and because he knew we would suck this year so he got an extra year on contract. wow.
grizatwork said:Thank you Mick for putting your heart and soul into our grizzlies this year. Thank you for holding your players accountable both on and off the field. Thank you for keeping things together this year with a new offensive coordinator, a new defensive coordinator, a couple new position coaches, a new athletic director, all the offseason junk. A whole new defense with one senior, an offense with no experienced quarteback. A new punter and kicker. Both freshman. This griz fan is eternally grateful and embarrassed by some of my fellow fans.
On a side note, we might have won a few more games if smithwick-hann started earlier in the season. At least his down field passes came close to his receivers. Something TM never could accomplish. TM was, is, and never will be the answer. SSH, AB, or gustafson need to be it next year.
PlayerRep said:Wolfman_Jack said:A major part of the head coach's job is to get kids to focus despite outside distractions, it's a valuable life skill that even average coaches can instill to their players.
This team obviously failed miserably at that task.
And obviously our HC isn't even average as a coach. And you want to give him credit because he wasn't the cause of the distractions, and because he knew we would suck this year so he got an extra year on contract. wow.
You don't know what you're talking about. The team and coaches did a terrific job focusing on the task at hand and playing under tough circumstances, including without their Payton Award list qb.
This is all true, with exception to the OC position.doebrmn said:As pointed out before the season started, there was a reason that he received a 2 year contract and it was not because UM asked for it, it is because he asked for it. He knew the season COULD likey turn out the way it did and he wanted the security of not getting thrown under the bus (like many Griz fans are already doing). THIS IS A GUESS, UM also understood there was a chance of some type of sanctions being handed down after the season that would affect its ability to recruit a new head coach. They wanted to make sure they had a HC in place and did not want Mick to just retire after the season if UM was facing some type of sanctions. This gives them another year of continuity to have a HC in place and then can start recruiting next year hoping that any NCAA issue is a one year deal or UM will at least be one year closer to having whatever it is over.
As for Mick, many posters are this board are forgetting that the Griz DC and OC left before the Sh*t storm. Plu hired the replacements. Coordinators are a huge part of a teams suceess. I think too much blame is being put on Mick. It is easy to say this is the same team Plu would have had except JJ, but that is not true. All the outside distractions take a toll. Had Plu stayed on that would have been one less distraction than what Mick dealt with. If JJ was still on the team that is two less distraction (and the main ones) that Mick would not have to deal with (of course he wouldn't be the HC, but you get the point). Finally, Mick didn't go out and buy drugs with 3 weeks left in the season. Another distraction that was not of his making.
Is he a great HC, I don't think so. You don't coach in the College ranks for 40 years and only make HC once unless it is clear you are better suited to be a position coach or Coordinator. But he stepped up when UM needed him, kept a team with many off-field distractions and on-field issues in a position to win all of its games. He deserves credit for that.
exactly correct! fantastarific post....uofmman1122 said:This is all true, with exception to the OC position.doebrmn said:As pointed out before the season started, there was a reason that he received a 2 year contract and it was not because UM asked for it, it is because he asked for it. He knew the season COULD likey turn out the way it did and he wanted the security of not getting thrown under the bus (like many Griz fans are already doing). THIS IS A GUESS, UM also understood there was a chance of some type of sanctions being handed down after the season that would affect its ability to recruit a new head coach. They wanted to make sure they had a HC in place and did not want Mick to just retire after the season if UM was facing some type of sanctions. This gives them another year of continuity to have a HC in place and then can start recruiting next year hoping that any NCAA issue is a one year deal or UM will at least be one year closer to having whatever it is over.
As for Mick, many posters are this board are forgetting that the Griz DC and OC left before the Sh*t storm. Plu hired the replacements. Coordinators are a huge part of a teams suceess. I think too much blame is being put on Mick. It is easy to say this is the same team Plu would have had except JJ, but that is not true. All the outside distractions take a toll. Had Plu stayed on that would have been one less distraction than what Mick dealt with. If JJ was still on the team that is two less distraction (and the main ones) that Mick would not have to deal with (of course he wouldn't be the HC, but you get the point). Finally, Mick didn't go out and buy drugs with 3 weeks left in the season. Another distraction that was not of his making.
Is he a great HC, I don't think so. You don't coach in the College ranks for 40 years and only make HC once unless it is clear you are better suited to be a position coach or Coordinator. But he stepped up when UM needed him, kept a team with many off-field distractions and on-field issues in a position to win all of its games. He deserves credit for that.
As I've said for a loooong time, Rosie was NOT brought in to run the offense.
Robin Pflugrad ran the offense, just like Chip Kelly does at Oregon.
The Oregon-style spread was Pflu's baby, and it's been painfully obvious no one on the staff knew how to run it. At all. Rosie was here for two months before Pflu was fired. There's no way he picked everything up that fast.
Our offense is probably more dependent on calling the correct play than any other offense in the big sky. It's all about creating mismatches and taking advantage of space and the numbers game. You dictate what the defense wants to do, and then take advantage of what they're not doing. And if you aren't calling the correct plays to set up the mismatches, it doesn't f***[*] work, ala exhibit A: this whole goddamn season.
We got yards because we have a fantastic offensive line and great athletes. We didn't score because the gameplay was all wrong, and teams had an easier time defending it more often than not.
Not to mention we got stuck playing our third and forth string QBs, although I think Pflu running the offense would have made them (especially McKinney) look much much better.
My dad texted me the day Pflu got fired letting me know, and my initial thought was "well, there goes the offense". I thought I was being melodramatic at the time, but looks about right, right now.
And yeah, our D didn't perform nearly as well as we expected, but I'd be willing to bet they would have looked much better if the offense didn't fail on 5-10 straight drives in a row every single game.
So yeah, distractions definitely killed this team, but the death blow was firing Pflu. That was by far the worst thing that happened, in this Griz fan's opinion.
stubbins said:exactly correct! fantastarific post....uofmman1122 said:This is all true, with exception to the OC position.doebrmn said:As pointed out before the season started, there was a reason that he received a 2 year contract and it was not because UM asked for it, it is because he asked for it. He knew the season COULD likey turn out the way it did and he wanted the security of not getting thrown under the bus (like many Griz fans are already doing). THIS IS A GUESS, UM also understood there was a chance of some type of sanctions being handed down after the season that would affect its ability to recruit a new head coach. They wanted to make sure they had a HC in place and did not want Mick to just retire after the season if UM was facing some type of sanctions. This gives them another year of continuity to have a HC in place and then can start recruiting next year hoping that any NCAA issue is a one year deal or UM will at least be one year closer to having whatever it is over.
As for Mick, many posters are this board are forgetting that the Griz DC and OC left before the Sh*t storm. Plu hired the replacements. Coordinators are a huge part of a teams suceess. I think too much blame is being put on Mick. It is easy to say this is the same team Plu would have had except JJ, but that is not true. All the outside distractions take a toll. Had Plu stayed on that would have been one less distraction than what Mick dealt with. If JJ was still on the team that is two less distraction (and the main ones) that Mick would not have to deal with (of course he wouldn't be the HC, but you get the point). Finally, Mick didn't go out and buy drugs with 3 weeks left in the season. Another distraction that was not of his making.
Is he a great HC, I don't think so. You don't coach in the College ranks for 40 years and only make HC once unless it is clear you are better suited to be a position coach or Coordinator. But he stepped up when UM needed him, kept a team with many off-field distractions and on-field issues in a position to win all of its games. He deserves credit for that.
As I've said for a loooong time, Rosie was NOT brought in to run the offense.
Robin Pflugrad ran the offense, just like Chip Kelly does at Oregon.
The Oregon-style spread was Pflu's baby, and it's been painfully obvious no one on the staff knew how to run it. At all. Rosie was here for two months before Pflu was fired. There's no way he picked everything up that fast.
Our offense is probably more dependent on calling the correct play than any other offense in the big sky. It's all about creating mismatches and taking advantage of space and the numbers game. You dictate what the defense wants to do, and then take advantage of what they're not doing. And if you aren't calling the correct plays to set up the mismatches, it doesn't f***[*] work, ala exhibit A: this whole goddamn season.
We got yards because we have a fantastic offensive line and great athletes. We didn't score because the gameplay was all wrong, and teams had an easier time defending it more often than not.
Not to mention we got stuck playing our third and forth string QBs, although I think Pflu running the offense would have made them (especially McKinney) look much much better.
My dad texted me the day Pflu got fired letting me know, and my initial thought was "well, there goes the offense". I thought I was being melodramatic at the time, but looks about right, right now.
And yeah, our D didn't perform nearly as well as we expected, but I'd be willing to bet they would have looked much better if the offense didn't fail on 5-10 straight drives in a row every single game.
So yeah, distractions definitely killed this team, but the death blow was firing Pflu. That was by far the worst thing that happened, in this Griz fan's opinion.
this is just a really really good post! one question, didnt J. Smith do alot of the playcalling aswell? i suspose i could be mistaken but i thought he did...but that is a moot point, your post was spot onuofmman1122 said:This is all true, with exception to the OC position.doebrmn said:As pointed out before the season started, there was a reason that he received a 2 year contract and it was not because UM asked for it, it is because he asked for it. He knew the season COULD likey turn out the way it did and he wanted the security of not getting thrown under the bus (like many Griz fans are already doing). THIS IS A GUESS, UM also understood there was a chance of some type of sanctions being handed down after the season that would affect its ability to recruit a new head coach. They wanted to make sure they had a HC in place and did not want Mick to just retire after the season if UM was facing some type of sanctions. This gives them another year of continuity to have a HC in place and then can start recruiting next year hoping that any NCAA issue is a one year deal or UM will at least be one year closer to having whatever it is over.
As for Mick, many posters are this board are forgetting that the Griz DC and OC left before the Sh*t storm. Plu hired the replacements. Coordinators are a huge part of a teams suceess. I think too much blame is being put on Mick. It is easy to say this is the same team Plu would have had except JJ, but that is not true. All the outside distractions take a toll. Had Plu stayed on that would have been one less distraction than what Mick dealt with. If JJ was still on the team that is two less distraction (and the main ones) that Mick would not have to deal with (of course he wouldn't be the HC, but you get the point). Finally, Mick didn't go out and buy drugs with 3 weeks left in the season. Another distraction that was not of his making.
Is he a great HC, I don't think so. You don't coach in the College ranks for 40 years and only make HC once unless it is clear you are better suited to be a position coach or Coordinator. But he stepped up when UM needed him, kept a team with many off-field distractions and on-field issues in a position to win all of its games. He deserves credit for that.
As I've said for a loooong time, Rosie was NOT brought in to run the offense.
Robin Pflugrad ran the offense, just like Chip Kelly does at Oregon.
The Oregon-style spread was Pflu's baby, and it's been painfully obvious no one on the staff knew how to run it. At all. Rosie was here for two months before Pflu was fired. There's no way he picked everything up that fast.
Our offense is probably more dependent on calling the correct play than any other offense in the big sky. It's all about creating mismatches and taking advantage of space and the numbers game. You dictate what the defense wants to do, and then take advantage of what they're not doing. And if you aren't calling the correct plays to set up the mismatches, it doesn't f***[*] work, ala exhibit A: this whole goddamn season.
We got yards because we have a fantastic offensive line and great athletes. We didn't score because the gameplay was all wrong, and teams had an easier time defending it more often than not.
Not to mention we got stuck playing our third and forth string QBs, although I think Pflu running the offense would have made them (especially McKinney) look much much better.
My dad texted me the day Pflu got fired letting me know, and my initial thought was "well, there goes the offense". I thought I was being melodramatic at the time, but looks about right, right now.
And yeah, our D didn't perform nearly as well as we expected, but I'd be willing to bet they would have looked much better if the offense didn't fail on 5-10 straight drives in a row every single game.
So yeah, distractions definitely killed this team, but the death blow was firing Pflu. That was by far the worst thing that happened, in this Griz fan's opinion.
is JJ still on the Payton list ?PlayerRep said:Wolfman_Jack said:A major part of the head coach's job is to get kids to focus despite outside distractions, it's a valuable life skill that even average coaches can instill to their players.
This team obviously failed miserably at that task.
And obviously our HC isn't even average as a coach. And you want to give him credit because he wasn't the cause of the distractions, and because he knew we would suck this year so he got an extra year on contract. wow.
You don't know what you're talking about. The team and coaches did a terrific job focusing on the task at hand and playing under tough circumstances, including without their Payton Award list qb.
next year when it first comes out he will be might beCats2506 said:is JJ still on the Payton list ?PlayerRep said:Wolfman_Jack said:A major part of the head coach's job is to get kids to focus despite outside distractions, it's a valuable life skill that even average coaches can instill to their players.
This team obviously failed miserably at that task.
And obviously our HC isn't even average as a coach. And you want to give him credit because he wasn't the cause of the distractions, and because he knew we would suck this year so he got an extra year on contract. wow.
You don't know what you're talking about. The team and coaches did a terrific job focusing on the task at hand and playing under tough circumstances, including without their Payton Award list qb.
That could be true, but as I understand it smith was always upstairs looking over the whole field. Pflu called the plays, smith took a look and saw what was up on defense, and sometimes called down to the field to tell him wait, that doesn't look good, and then you saw the Griz all look to the sideline for the call. But especially when we were in the hurry up, Pflu was leading the offense.becker2117 said:this is just a really really good post! one question, didnt J. Smith do alot of the playcalling aswell? i suspose i could be mistaken but i thought he did...but that is a moot point, your post was spot onuofmman1122 said:This is all true, with exception to the OC position.doebrmn said:As pointed out before the season started, there was a reason that he received a 2 year contract and it was not because UM asked for it, it is because he asked for it. He knew the season COULD likey turn out the way it did and he wanted the security of not getting thrown under the bus (like many Griz fans are already doing). THIS IS A GUESS, UM also understood there was a chance of some type of sanctions being handed down after the season that would affect its ability to recruit a new head coach. They wanted to make sure they had a HC in place and did not want Mick to just retire after the season if UM was facing some type of sanctions. This gives them another year of continuity to have a HC in place and then can start recruiting next year hoping that any NCAA issue is a one year deal or UM will at least be one year closer to having whatever it is over.
As for Mick, many posters are this board are forgetting that the Griz DC and OC left before the Sh*t storm. Plu hired the replacements. Coordinators are a huge part of a teams suceess. I think too much blame is being put on Mick. It is easy to say this is the same team Plu would have had except JJ, but that is not true. All the outside distractions take a toll. Had Plu stayed on that would have been one less distraction than what Mick dealt with. If JJ was still on the team that is two less distraction (and the main ones) that Mick would not have to deal with (of course he wouldn't be the HC, but you get the point). Finally, Mick didn't go out and buy drugs with 3 weeks left in the season. Another distraction that was not of his making.
Is he a great HC, I don't think so. You don't coach in the College ranks for 40 years and only make HC once unless it is clear you are better suited to be a position coach or Coordinator. But he stepped up when UM needed him, kept a team with many off-field distractions and on-field issues in a position to win all of its games. He deserves credit for that.
As I've said for a loooong time, Rosie was NOT brought in to run the offense.
Robin Pflugrad ran the offense, just like Chip Kelly does at Oregon.
The Oregon-style spread was Pflu's baby, and it's been painfully obvious no one on the staff knew how to run it. At all. Rosie was here for two months before Pflu was fired. There's no way he picked everything up that fast.
Our offense is probably more dependent on calling the correct play than any other offense in the big sky. It's all about creating mismatches and taking advantage of space and the numbers game. You dictate what the defense wants to do, and then take advantage of what they're not doing. And if you aren't calling the correct plays to set up the mismatches, it doesn't f***[*] work, ala exhibit A: this whole goddamn season.
We got yards because we have a fantastic offensive line and great athletes. We didn't score because the gameplay was all wrong, and teams had an easier time defending it more often than not.
Not to mention we got stuck playing our third and forth string QBs, although I think Pflu running the offense would have made them (especially McKinney) look much much better.
My dad texted me the day Pflu got fired letting me know, and my initial thought was "well, there goes the offense". I thought I was being melodramatic at the time, but looks about right, right now.
And yeah, our D didn't perform nearly as well as we expected, but I'd be willing to bet they would have looked much better if the offense didn't fail on 5-10 straight drives in a row every single game.
So yeah, distractions definitely killed this team, but the death blow was firing Pflu. That was by far the worst thing that happened, in this Griz fan's opinion.