Did Bobby recruit Mellott?

[Spanky2]

So what’s your point Jesse? Are you trying to bad mouth Coach Hauck because a player didn’t make it at a given position or at all? As for Brown, it will depend on whether or not he remains in the program, but maybe he still makes it. Who knows?

Spank my point is someone on the staff is doing a piss poor job of scouting and recruiting qbs. Am I wrong?

There isn’t a guarantee attached when they are recruited that they will make it at a given position. The Helena recruit looks good that he may be a future Griz QB, but if he doesn’t pan out, is that Bobby’s fault? Let’s hope they can attract a good drop down in the near future.

 

[Jesse]

Spank my point is someone on the staff is doing a piss poor job of scouting and recruiting qbs. Am I wrong?

There isn’t a guarantee attached when they are recruited that they will make it at a given position. The Helena recruit looks good that he may be a future Griz QB, but if he doesn’t pan out, is that Bobby’s fault? Let’s hope they can attract a good drop down in the near future.

I’m not saying it’s anyone’s fault but it’s been what 4 recruiting classes now and will you know what happened in the JMU game.

 

[Spanky2]

There isn’t a guarantee attached when they are recruited that they will make it at a given position. The Helena recruit looks good that he may be a future Griz QB, but if he doesn’t pan out, is that Bobby’s fault? Let’s hope they can attract a good drop down in the near future.

I’m not saying it’s anyone’s fault but it’s been what 4 recruiting classes now and will you know what happened in the JMU game.

Jesse, give credit to the great year the Griz had: wins over Washington, Eastern Washington, Montana State. Not too bad!
Our starting QB was injured and had to leave the JMU game and the two backups couldn’t get the job done.

 

[Jesse]

I’m not saying it’s anyone’s fault but it’s been what 4 recruiting classes now and will you know what happened in the JMU game.

Jesse, give credit to the great year the Griz had: wins over Washington, Eastern Washington, Montana State. Not too bad!
Our starting QB was injured and had to leave the JMU game and the two backups couldn’t get the job done.

I know and this defense was built for a title run. The offense was the Achilles specifically lack of depth at qb. But a great year none the less. The huskie win will go down as one of greatest wins in school history. Im just disappointed watching the cats incredible run through the bracket and into the chipper. I hope they win, but goddamn the Griz were the better team, but just snake bit with injuries.

 

[AZGrizFan]

Spank my point is someone on the staff is doing a piss poor job of scouting and recruiting qbs. Am I wrong?

There isn’t a guarantee attached when they are recruited that they will make it at a given position. The Helena recruit looks good that he may be a future Griz QB, but if he doesn’t pan out, is that Bobby’s fault? Let’s hope they can attract a good drop down in the near future.

If it's not the head coach's fault, who's is it? :? :?

There's been shitloads of ink spilled on this very site about the shitty recruits Stitt brought in and how few of them "panned out"....was that not Stitt's fault either?

 

[Spanky2]

There isn’t a guarantee attached when they are recruited that they will make it at a given position. The Helena recruit looks good that he may be a future Griz QB, but if he doesn’t pan out, is that Bobby’s fault? Let’s hope they can attract a good drop down in the near future.

If it's not the head coach's fault, who's is it? :? :?

There's been shitloads of ink spilled on this very site about the shitty recruits Stitt brought in and how few of them "panned out"....was that not Stitt's fault either?

You can’t compare Stitt to Bobby. Stitt isn’t a coach, much closer to a used car salesman.we know you loved Stitt. To each his own.

 

[AZGrizFan]

If it's not the head coach's fault, who's is it? :? :?

There's been shitloads of ink spilled on this very site about the shitty recruits Stitt brought in and how few of them "panned out"....was that not Stitt's fault either?

You can’t compare Stitt to Bobby. Stitt isn’t a coach, much closer to a used car salesman.we know you loved Stitt. To each his own.

I sure as fuck can. Both got paid to do the same thing. But apparently we now know how much you love Hauck.

 

[Spanky2]

You can’t compare Stitt to Bobby. Stitt isn’t a coach, much closer to a used car salesman.we know you loved Stitt. To each his own.

I sure as [#]f### can. Both got paid to do the same thing. But apparently we now know how much you love Hauck.

Yes, I think he is an excellent coach and UM is fortunate to have him.

 

[AZGrizFan]

I sure as [#]f### can. Both got paid to do the same thing. But apparently we now know how much you love Hauck.

Yes, I think he is an excellent coach and UM is fortunate to have him.

As do I. It doesn’t change the fact that if there’s not sufficient depth at a position ultimately it’s HE who is responsible. Especially in year FOUR. He can’t just wave the “well, too bad none of them panned out” flag and get off Scott free just because you ”think he’s an excellent coach and UM is fortunate to have him”.

 

[grizband]

Yes, I think he is an excellent coach and UM is fortunate to have him.

As do I. It doesn’t change the fact that if there’s not sufficient depth at a position ultimately it’s HE who is responsible. Especially in year FOUR. He can’t just wave the “well, too bad none of them panned out” flag and get off Scott free just because you ”think he’s an excellent coach and UM is fortunate to have him”.

This...shouldn't all coaches be held to similar standards?

 

[AZGrizFan]

As do I. It doesn’t change the fact that if there’s not sufficient depth at a position ultimately it’s HE who is responsible. Especially in year FOUR. He can’t just wave the “well, too bad none of them panned out” flag and get off Scott free just because you ”think he’s an excellent coach and UM is fortunate to have him”.

This...shouldn't all coaches be held to similar standards?

Not according to Spanky. Just the ones he doesn’t like.

 

[argh!]

I’m not saying it’s anyone’s fault but it’s been what 4 recruiting classes now and will you know what happened in the JMU game.

Jesse, give credit to the great year the Griz had: wins over Washington, Eastern Washington, Montana State. Not too bad!
Our starting QB was injured and had to leave the JMU game and the two backups couldn’t get the job done.

i remember three seasons in a row when the griz lost their best qbs to injury for multiple games, including losing a very good qb for the season in the second or third game. i don't remember spanky making excuses then.

 

[CDAGRIZ]

Fellas, we can’t expect instant results. This process is gonna take some time. In seven more years after the other teams have gone FBS, you’ll see us begin to think about starting the process of becoming a program that’s about to take a look at RTD.

 

[AZGrizFan]

Fellas, we can’t expect instant results. This process is gonna take some time. In seven more years after the other teams have gone FBS, you’ll see us begin to think about starting the process of becoming a program that’s about to take a look at RTD.

I can hardly wait, CDA. :thumb:

 

[gotgame75]

Yes, I think he is an excellent coach and UM is fortunate to have him.

As do I. It doesn’t change the fact that if there’s not sufficient depth at a position ultimately it’s HE who is responsible. Especially in year FOUR. He can’t just wave the “well, too bad none of them panned out” flag and get off Scott free just because you ”think he’s an excellent coach and UM is fortunate to have him”.

:clap: :clap: :clap:

Bobby is a very good (not great, great coaches win titles and road playoff games) HC, but that does not make him immune to criticism. He is not some Saban-esque elite coaching god that is irreplaceable, as many Griz fans seem to think. He gets the benefit of the doubt among much of Griz Nation in ways that boggle my mind, the recruiting failures at QB included.

 

[WaGriz4life]

As do I. It doesn’t change the fact that if there’s not sufficient depth at a position ultimately it’s HE who is responsible. Especially in year FOUR. He can’t just wave the “well, too bad none of them panned out” flag and get off Scott free just because you ”think he’s an excellent coach and UM is fortunate to have him”.

:clap: :clap: :clap:

Bobby is a very good (not great, great coaches win titles and road playoff games) HC, but that does not make him immune to criticism. He is not some Saban-esque elite coaching god that is irreplaceable, as many Griz fans seem to think. He gets the benefit of the doubt among much of Griz Nation in ways that boggle my mind, the recruiting failures at QB included.

You guys think we are USC and it is hilarious. We are a small time college football program in Missoula, Montana. Yeah we need to be able to roll in all conference type players at every position, no excuse. We should move on from a coach who is 108-29 overall and 63-14 in the Big Sky. But I guess I just accept mediocrity.

 

[WaGriz4life]

As do I. It doesn’t change the fact that if there’s not sufficient depth at a position ultimately it’s HE who is responsible. Especially in year FOUR. He can’t just wave the “well, too bad none of them panned out” flag and get off Scott free just because you ”think he’s an excellent coach and UM is fortunate to have him”.

:clap: :clap: :clap:

Bobby is a very good (not great, great coaches win titles and road playoff games) HC, but that does not make him immune to criticism. He is not some Saban-esque elite coaching god that is irreplaceable, as many Griz fans seem to think. He gets the benefit of the doubt among much of Griz Nation in ways that boggle my mind, the recruiting failures at QB included.

Recruiting failures at QB. I can’t wait for you to argue with me about this. You start, and I’ll finish with Andrew Selle, Dalton Sneed, and Cam Humphrey. Can’t wait for you to talk shit about those guys.

 

[fanofzoo]

:clap: :clap: :clap:

Bobby is a very good (not great, great coaches win titles and road playoff games) HC, but that does not make him immune to criticism. He is not some Saban-esque elite coaching god that is irreplaceable, as many Griz fans seem to think. He gets the benefit of the doubt among much of Griz Nation in ways that boggle my mind, the recruiting failures at QB included.

You guys think we are USC and it is hilarious. We are a small time college football program in Missoula, Montana. Yeah we need to be able to roll in all conference type players at every position, no excuse. We should move on from a coach who is 108-29 overall and 63-14 in the Big Sky. But I guess I just accept mediocrity.

Well his record of losing the chipper has got to be up there.

 

[indian-outlaw]

:clap: :clap: :clap:

Bobby is a very good (not great, great coaches win titles and road playoff games) HC, but that does not make him immune to criticism. He is not some Saban-esque elite coaching god that is irreplaceable, as many Griz fans seem to think. He gets the benefit of the doubt among much of Griz Nation in ways that boggle my mind, the recruiting failures at QB included.

Recruiting failures at QB. I can’t wait for you to argue with me about this. You start, and I’ll finish with Andrew Selle, Dalton Sneed, and Cam Humphrey. Can’t wait for you to talk shit about those guys.

Nobody is going to shit talk those guys. But alongside our rival to the west how do they compare to Eric Meyer, Matt Nichols, Bo Levi Mitchell, Vernon Adams and Eric Barrier? Why can bobby not out recruit them? Or does eastern develope them better?

 

[kemajic]

You guys think we are USC and it is hilarious. We are a small time college football program in Missoula, Montana. Yeah we need to be able to roll in all conference type players at every position, no excuse. We should move on from a coach who is 108-29 overall and 63-14 in the Big Sky. But I guess I just accept mediocrity.

Well his record of losing the chipper has got to be up there.

Leave it to you for another outstanding contribution. Your special Christmas Greeting for Griz fans.