• Hi Guest, want to participate in the discussions, keep track of read/unread posts access private forums and more? Create your free account and increase the benefits of your eGriz.com experience today!

A review of Krakauer's book on campus rape

browningmontana

Well-known member
Krakauer’s New Book on Campus Rape
In ‘Missoula: Rape and the Justice System in a College Town,’ author Jon Krakauer (‘Into Thin Air,’ ‘Into the Wild’) explores campus rape


April 16, 2015 9:38 p.m. ET
15 COMMENTS
In 2013, Jon Krakauer was at a Missoula, Mont., sentencing hearing for a college football player accused of rape. Transfixed by the victim’s steely testimony, the author of “Into Thin Air” and the classroom staple “Into the Wild” had a eureka moment: This might be a book. During a break, he approached one of the victim’s friends in the crowded courtroom.

“She was very, like, ‘Uh-oh, there’s this creepy old guy,’” said Mr. Krakauer, who just turned 61, in an interview. But she agreed to pass along a note to the victim. After Mr. Krakauer scribbled his name, the woman remembered “Into the Wild,” and blurted out: “They made us read your stupid book in high school!”

Mr. Krakauer’s “Missoula: Rape and the Justice System in a College Town,” due Tuesday from Doubleday, tracks a number of sexual-assault cases involving students at the University of Montana. The publisher plans an initial run of 500,000 copies, reflecting the timely matchup of a best-selling writer and a hot-button issue.

“Missoula” lands just weeks after a scathing report from Columbia University’s Graduate School of Journalism on Rolling Stone’s now-discredited article alleging a gang rape in a University of Virginia fraternity.

The book goes beyond the drumbeat of news reports and statistics, examining the subject through the prism of picturesque Missoula, a small city dominated by a university with a popular football team. Mr. Krakauer dissects several sexual-assault cases that happened between 2010 and 2012 and tracks their progress through the University of Montana, the Missoula Police Department and the Missoula County Attorney’s Office. In 2012, the U.S. Department of Justice began investigating how the university and local authorities were handling sexual-assault cases, leading to changes in procedures. In Mr. Krakauer’s book, the outcomes of the cases for the accused rapists ranged from being dropped for lack of evidence to prison.

Advertisement

While he was a student at Hampshire College during the 1970s, a girlfriend told him she had been raped, Mr. Krakauer said. At the time he grasped neither the breadth of the problem nor its consequences. But in 2012, after learning that a friend had been preyed upon as a teenager and again as a young woman, he began reading up on sexual assault. He hadn’t intended to write about the problem, just to get a sense of its frequency and effect.

“I’m kind of an obsessive type,” Mr. Krakauer said. “Once you just start digging, if you just tell yourself ‘No, just keep digging, another few shovel holes,’ you find that inevitably there’s always stuff there buried deep.”

Relying on police reports, recordings of university disciplinary proceedings, court documents and other material, Mr. Krakauer knits diverse—and often conflicting—memories and motivations into a narrative. He depicts victims and the accused, their families and friends, university officials, law-enforcement authorities, lawyers and health professionals. Through heated exchanges among officials, Mr. Krakauer portrays the pressures on institutions and authorities to respect the rights of both accuser and accused in complex cases with life-destroying consequences.

Mr. Krakauer also talked to psychologists and scholars about the trauma of rape, exploring the corrosive toll of sexual assault on a typical American college town. “Missoula” revisits how the encounters unfolded, the victims’ anguish about coming forward and the alleged rapists’ horror and disbelief at being accused. One victim and the man accused of raping her had been friends since first grade, but never romantically linked.

One takeaway from “Missoula” is that every incident of alleged rape is different, and ambiguities abound. Mr. Krakauer provides no sweeping conclusions. The age-old problem of rape by nonstrangers can only be solved incrementally, he said, and recent improvements in how cases are handled are encouraging.

“I write these books for things that I become obsessed with. I don’t delude myself into thinking I’m going to change the world,” he said.

Campus rape isn’t a recent epidemic, Mr. Krakauer added, but rather “a scourge that’s always been there and it’s just now coming to light because women are being emboldened” to come forward.

“Into the Wild,” Mr. Krakauer’s first best seller, was about a young adventurer who expired in the Alaskan wilderness. Published in 1996, the book is a perennial on high-school and college syllabuses. The author followed with “Into Thin Air,” a first-person account of an Everest expedition in which a number of people died. He then wrote “Under the Banner of Heaven,” about murder among a Mormon splinter group, and “Where Men Win Glory,” on the life and death of football star turned Army Ranger, Pat Tillman. At first, the shift in subject flummoxed his publishers, Mr. Krakauer said. An editor asked: “Jon, where are the mountains?” But readers gobbled these up, too.

Despite his success, Mr. Krakauer doesn’t strive to be a public figure and is seldom recognized. “Missoula” has been kept under wraps, and no book tour is in the works. But he has one appearance on his calendar—in Montana, where some saw their community as unfairly singled out.

“I felt I needed to do something in Missoula to allow my critics to confront me,” he said. Fact & Fiction, a local bookstore, is organizing an event next month, said Eamon Fahey, the store’s chief operating officer. To allow for a big audience, the event will be held not at the store but a nearby hotel.

Asked which schools now deal effectively with sexual-assault complaints, Mr. Krakauer said, “Ironically, I think the University of Montana probably has it somewhat right because the DOJ forced them to get it right.”

According to a statement from the University of Montana, the school is “stronger, safer and better aligned with best practices because of our continuing work on policies, training and programs—both those implemented before the federal government’s investigations and since.”
 
Katie Baker, the author of the review, is the author of the Jezebel.com article entitled something like Rape Capital of the US and an article critical of Kirsten Pabst.
 
This was the same gal who kept trying to tell the local girls they didn't know what they were talking about when they explained the Missoula scene. Was a laugher of an article. Big city gal "informs" backwater local gals on how their town operates.
 
This quote stood out to me, "alleged rapists’ horror and disbelief at being accused". Maybe it won't be the take on JJ you guys think it will. Maybe it will, maybe it won't. I'll be buying it Tuesday and then reading on my plane ride to NV on Thursday. Course I'll have to stay off of egriz for a few days so I don't get any spoilers. :lol:
 
I will not buy that book. I will rely on others to give me info just like what's his name. I will be there to give my support to the side that was found NOT GUILTY in a court of law.
 
"On campus, ... UM Dean of Students Charles Couture was a swift and uncompromising investigator of student assaults, a man who delivered justice for young women more effectively than law enforcement, according to cases the book presents."
Asked which schools now deal effectively with sexual-assault complaints, Mr. Krakauer said, “Ironically, I think the University of Montana probably has it somewhat right because the DOJ forced them to get it right.”
So, UM had a system in place that "delivered justice for young women more effectively than law enforcement," and offered "swift and uncompromising investigation of student assaults," but UM also had to "be forced to get it right?"

WTF?
 
Couture was another limp kneed UM official that was and is a joke in my mind. He and his friend Pat Williams sat in overstuffed chairs lamenting about the "gang rape" by UM football players and could not wait to get their opinion out to the Florios, Krakaurers, Engstroms and others. Couture let the guilty Saudi student leave with out a word. Not a football player so his rape was OK? Total lost souls all of them!
 
An NPR review/article:

"They were all acquaintance rapes. They were, for the most part, students. They were all in Missoula, which turns out is a pretty typical town. I don't mean to single out Missoula: Its rape rate is a little less than the national average; I think its problems with dealing with rape are pretty depressingly typical."

Note this phrase: "Its [Missoula's] rape rate is a little less than the national average".

"there were 230 rapes in town, most of which either weren't prosecuted or the prosecutions were bungled."

Really, he knows that were 230 "rapes". I wonder if there were even that many actual rapes, as opposed to some type of sexual assaults, reported. And he knows the prosecutions of "most" were "bungled", without having talked to the police or prosecutors or seeing the actual files. Must have just talked to accusers and the support group types. No way to he talked to 230 accusers to know that "most" prosecutions were bungled.

"I, for the most part, did not have cooperation of any law enforcement. I relied on records that I'm not supposed to have. I relied on documents. You know, I needed a paper trail. I needed to know the truth. I really had to be solid. ... I interviewed victims at great length. I tried to interview the rapists — only one of them actually talked to me on the record. But I had thousands and thousands of pages of trial transcripts, hearing transcripts. I had recordings."

So he used documents he wasn't "supposed to have"? Were they legally or illegally obtained?

"And you know, the fact that my book was rushed into print — it originally wasn't going to come out until next fall but my publisher and I decided, in part because of the Rolling Stone mess, that it'd be a good time to show this book; that no ... the overwhelming majority, you know, of victims do not lie about rape."

http://www.npr.org/2015/04/19/400185648/jon-krakauer-tells-a-depressingly-typical-story-of-college-town-rapes?utm_medium=RSS&utm_campaign=artslife" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
 
PlayerRep said:
"And you know, the fact that my book was rushed into print — it originally wasn't going to come out until next fall but my publisher and I decided, in part because of the Rolling Stone mess, that it'd be a good time to show this book; that no ... the overwhelming majority, you know, of victims do not lie about rape."
http://www.npr.org/2015/04/19/400185648/jon-krakauer-tells-a-depressingly-typical-story-of-college-town-rapes?utm_medium=RSS&utm_campaign=artslife" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
Once in a while, you run across a claim that is such a monstrous straw man fallacy, and so obviously dishonest as to motive, you wonder if the guy is that stupid, or he thinks everybody else is that stupid.

Who claimed that "the overwhelming majority of victims lie about rape?"
Where was the claim even remotely suggested?

How on earth does that have anything to do with "rapes" at the University of Montana, or the doubled frequency of such claims at Montana State University?
 
statler & waldorf said:
If this whole affair was properly investigated, a lot of people would bit the dust. Stonewalling at UM which would make Nixon blush.

you go, harry!
 
PlayerRep said:
An NPR review/article, Krakauer: "I tried to interview the rapists — only one of them actually talked to me on the record."
No confirmation bias there, is there?

The problem is, there were six athletes involved in nine incidents in the 13 month period. Four of the athletes committed no "rape" as the key witness, the woman's roommate, had taken a video of the "proceedings," showing not just the enthusiastic and laughing participation of the woman, but the initiation of sexual contact. The "problem" was "boyfriend found out," and as too often happens, suddenly a perfectly voluntary liaison becomes "I was raped." No rapists there.

I doubt that Krakauer notes that the vast majority of the alleged athlete rapes in that time frame (nearly 70%) involved a demonstrated fabulist who was trying to placate an angry boyfriend.

Donaldson pleaded guilty. Rapist. A typical "campus" rape, or athlete rape? Far from it.

JJ was found not guilty. No rapist. Likely fabulist involved.

Krakauer wouldn't tell that story, that nearly 90% of the athletes accused in the 13 month period were accused by people who's stories were either plainly fabricated, or which a unanimous jury found uncredible. The "epidemic" on campus was the high rate of false charges.

So, if Krakauher was only able to interview "one rapist," presumably an athlete, he managed to interview the only rapist.
 
Back
Top