• Hi Guest, want to participate in the discussions, keep track of read/unread posts access private forums and more? Create your free account and increase the benefits of your eGriz.com experience today!

2019 Griz RB's

Merkleman said:
mtgrizfankb said:
grzz said:
George Ferguson said:
I believe it actually does. Bell preserved his red-shirt by only playing in four games. He never actually made it to San Diego State because he didn't qualify academically. He signed, but never ended up enrolling. He was at a JUCO for two years, then went to Nebraska and played in four games. I actually do believe he is free to go to another FBS school, unless I'm missing something.

Also, I don't know if I would consider his Twitter as an insight into what he's doing either. Yes, these days, MOST of these kids you can get a good sense, but, he literally never posts anything about himself, and if you're just going by followers and following to say there's a "buzz" with the Griz. Well, he follows two Griz coaches and Akem, but he also follows Choate and Orphey too, so I guess there's a buzz with him possibly going to MSU too.

He played in games at Nebraska this year. Yes only four so this became his redshirt year, but just by red shirting doesn't fulfill the academic year at your new institution requirement for a same level transfer without a waiver. Think of Robby Hauck, all he did was redshirt at NAU and he still had to get waiver approval to be eligible this year from both the Big Sky and the NCAA.

If Bell wanted to transfer to any FBS school he would need a waiver approval to play right away. If it didn't get approved he would lose his junior year sitting out. Unless you can find something in the NCAA transfer manual I am missing.

You are mixing up all sorts of rules. The big sky conference does not allow inner conference transfers. That’s why Robby needed a waiver. The big sky was blocking the transfer not the ncaa. Nebraska already did block Oregon state and all other inner conference members from Bell. So bell at this point after redshirting means he can go anywhere outside of his conference and that was not written into his release (al la Oregon state) many upper fbs schools won’t take him because he’s a 1-1 year player without a huge track record of success. Many other FBS programs will welcome him however, as will fcs programs

While Robby didn’t need a waiver from the NCAA to transfer to Montana, he did have to request a hardship waiver from the NCAA to not have to sit this past season. The initial request was denied by the NCAA and reversed when appealed.

Only in the case of hardship or graduating can a player transfer to the same level or up a level and not have to sit.
In short, unless Bell graduates he will have to drop down to play next year.

100% correct. Not hard to understand:

FBS to FBS - sit a year
FBS to FCS - play immediately
FCS to FCS - sit a year

* only exception is a grad transfer like Vernon Adams going to Oregon.

And yes Robby needed approval not to sit out this year from NAU first, then the Big Sky, then the NCAA. The NCAA is trying to change intraconference transfer rules in the future but right now it’s up to each individual conference
 
HookedonGriz said:
Merkleman said:
mtgrizfankb said:
grzz said:
He played in games at Nebraska this year. Yes only four so this became his redshirt year, but just by red shirting doesn't fulfill the academic year at your new institution requirement for a same level transfer without a waiver. Think of Robby Hauck, all he did was redshirt at NAU and he still had to get waiver approval to be eligible this year from both the Big Sky and the NCAA.

If Bell wanted to transfer to any FBS school he would need a waiver approval to play right away. If it didn't get approved he would lose his junior year sitting out. Unless you can find something in the NCAA transfer manual I am missing.

You are mixing up all sorts of rules. The big sky conference does not allow inner conference transfers. That’s why Robby needed a waiver. The big sky was blocking the transfer not the ncaa. Nebraska already did block Oregon state and all other inner conference members from Bell. So bell at this point after redshirting means he can go anywhere outside of his conference and that was not written into his release (al la Oregon state) many upper fbs schools won’t take him because he’s a 1-1 year player without a huge track record of success. Many other FBS programs will welcome him however, as will fcs programs

While Robby didn’t need a waiver from the NCAA to transfer to Montana, he did have to request a hardship waiver from the NCAA to not have to sit this past season. The initial request was denied by the NCAA and reversed when appealed.

Only in the case of hardship or graduating can a player transfer to the same level or up a level and not have to sit.
In short, unless Bell graduates he will have to drop down to play next year.

100% correct. Not hard to understand:

FBS to FBS - sit a year
FBS to FCS - play immediately
FCS to FCS - sit a year

* only exception is a grad transfer like Vernon Adams going to Oregon.

And yes Robby needed approval not to sit out this year from NAU first, then the Big Sky, then the NCAA. The NCAA is trying to change intraconference transfer rules in the future but right now it’s up to each individual conference

Hey mtgrizfankb, you can acknowledge you were wrong if you would like ;-).
 
Merkleman or others, Bell looks terrific and runs hard and straight ahead (at least when that's the right move). But look at his youtube highlights from what I believe is the Colorado game. Twice when he broke, he was caught. Once, a Colo player seemed to run him down toward the sideline and downfield. On the other, more down the middle, Bell didn't necessary have time to fully regain his balance and speed.

I'm just focusing on your speed comment.
 
PlayerRep said:
Merkleman or others, Bell looks terrific and runs hard and straight ahead (at least when that's the right move). But look at his youtube highlights from what I believe is the Colorado game. Twice when he broke, he was caught. Once, a Colo player seemed to run him down toward the sideline and downfield. On the other, more down the middle, Bell didn't necessary have time to fully regain his balance and speed.

I'm just focusing on your speed comment.

Happens in football all the time. Faster guy sometimes gets caught by a slower guy for various reasons. Never said he was the fastest guy in the country. In my opinion, for a RB it’s how fast you can hit a hole and how fast you can get to top speed.

Ps. He officially visited during the UC Davis game.

Not for you.....but the haters here can thank the former Griz player later. I personally wouldn’t have taken the high road but he is his own person.
 
Spanky2 said:
Copper Griz said:
It would be nice to see a drop down back who can fill the void Calhoun left. Having said that, the receiving corps is ridiculously loaded with talent. What SA was doing to the Bobcats should be a much more frequent occurrence. JLM and Sulser (others as well) have speed and quicks that are superior most of the other teams in the Big sky. If the O Line gels and there is a semblance of a running game, look out. This offense could be lethal. Sneed also needs to have the time to make a read beyond his first go to. I believe this offense could be brutally effective in 2019 and especially in 2020.
Yes, if the OL wakes up from their long sleep.

Spanksterino, don't you find it odd that the O-line always blocked better for Calhoun than for Eastwood? I find that odd. Don't you find it odd?
 
Merkleman said:
PlayerRep said:
Merkleman or others, Bell looks terrific and runs hard and straight ahead (at least when that's the right move). But look at his youtube highlights from what I believe is the Colorado game. Twice when he broke, he was caught. Once, a Colo player seemed to run him down toward the sideline and downfield. On the other, more down the middle, Bell didn't necessary have time to fully regain his balance and speed.

I'm just focusing on your speed comment.

Happens in football all the time. Faster guy sometimes gets caught by a slower guy for various reasons. Never said he was the fastest guy in the country. In my opinion, for a RB it’s how fast you can hit a hole and how fast you can get to top speed.

Ps. He officially visited during the UC Davis game.

Not for you.....but the haters here can thank the former Griz player later. I personally wouldn’t have taken the high road but he is his own person.

So you’re saying the former player took the high road and spoke well of it here when he didn’t need to and that will factor in?
 
Merkleman said:
Not for you.....but the haters here can thank the former Griz player later. I personally wouldn’t have taken the high road but he is his own person.

So what you are saying is that you are a douche?
 
PlayerRep said:
Merkleman or others, Bell looks terrific and runs hard and straight ahead (at least when that's the right move). But look at his youtube highlights from what I believe is the Colorado game. Twice when he broke, he was caught. Once, a Colo player seemed to run him down toward the sideline and downfield. On the other, more down the middle, Bell didn't necessary have time to fully regain his balance and speed.

I'm just focusing on your speed comment.

This is very odd since no one on the defense is allowed to have speed...or more speed than a running back.
 
PlayerRep said:
Think this is link to Colo game highlights:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r8-NdRHuJn8

Same player caught him both times. #1 for Colorado...that dude is fast. :lol: :lol:
 
The way he hits a hole is much better than any RB currently listed with the Griz. Eastwood is not our answer.
 
grizindabox said:
Merkleman said:
Not for you.....but the haters here can thank the former Griz player later. I personally wouldn’t have taken the high road but he is his own person.

So what you are saying is that you are a douche?

Come on. Leave him alone. He provided some good info. It looks like his son took the high road. That's good for the Griz. Parents always protect their kids. Don't you?
 
PlayerRep said:
grizindabox said:
Merkleman said:
Not for you.....but the haters here can thank the former Griz player later. I personally wouldn’t have taken the high road but he is his own person.

So what you are saying is that you are a douche?

Come on. Leave him alone. He provided some good info. It looks like his son took the high road. That's good for the Griz. Parents always protect their kids. Don't you?

Yeah agreed no need to sling insults.
 
dayday said:
PlayerRep said:
grizindabox said:
Merkleman said:
Not for you.....but the haters here can thank the former Griz player later. I personally wouldn’t have taken the high road but he is his own person.

So what you are saying is that you are a douche?

Come on. Leave him alone. He provided some good info. It looks like his son took the high road. That's good for the Griz. Parents always protect their kids. Don't you?

Yeah agreed no need to sling insults.

Meh. Pretty sure he can find another message board....heard there were several MAC boards....even a MW board available.

Bottom line is his info is suspect. He is not a fan of Hauck...or Baer. That's fine. I get it. But, treat his posts for what they are and consider the obvious bias.
 
We really really need a back like Bell. Got I hope we can land him. Day day you seem to be in the know so please keep us updated on him. In fact somebody call Bobby and find out if we r gonna get this guy.
 
dayday said:
PlayerRep said:
grizindabox said:
Merkleman said:
Not for you.....but the haters here can thank the former Griz player later. I personally wouldn’t have taken the high road but he is his own person.

So what you are saying is that you are a douche?

Come on. Leave him alone. He provided some good info. It looks like his son took the high road. That's good for the Griz. Parents always protect their kids. Don't you?

Yeah agreed no need to sling insults.

Seems to me it has nothing to do with protecting his kid and more to do with bad mouthing the coach. There was no reason he needed to add that part to the post.
 
Grizwold said:
We really really need a back like Bell. Got I hope we can land him. Day day you seem to be in the know so please keep us updated on him. In fact somebody call Bobby and find out if we r gonna get this guy.

Janacaro is as good
 
AllWeatherFan said:
Spanky2 said:
Copper Griz said:
It would be nice to see a drop down back who can fill the void Calhoun left. Having said that, the receiving corps is ridiculously loaded with talent. What SA was doing to the Bobcats should be a much more frequent occurrence. JLM and Sulser (others as well) have speed and quicks that are superior most of the other teams in the Big sky. If the O Line gels and there is a semblance of a running game, look out. This offense could be lethal. Sneed also needs to have the time to make a read beyond his first go to. I believe this offense could be brutally effective in 2019 and especially in 2020.
Yes, if the OL wakes up from their long sleep.

Spanksterino, don't you find it odd that the O-line always blocked better for Calhoun than for Eastwood? I find that odd. Don't you find it odd?
Online didn’t block well for anyone. Calhoun was a better back than Eastwood.
 
Spanky2 said:
AllWeatherFan said:
Spanky2 said:
Copper Griz said:
It would be nice to see a drop down back who can fill the void Calhoun left. Having said that, the receiving corps is ridiculously loaded with talent. What SA was doing to the Bobcats should be a much more frequent occurrence. JLM and Sulser (others as well) have speed and quicks that are superior most of the other teams in the Big sky. If the O Line gels and there is a semblance of a running game, look out. This offense could be lethal. Sneed also needs to have the time to make a read beyond his first go to. I believe this offense could be brutally effective in 2019 and especially in 2020.
Yes, if the OL wakes up from their long sleep.

Spanksterino, don't you find it odd that the O-line always blocked better for Calhoun than for Eastwood? I find that odd. Don't you find it odd?
Online didn’t block well for anyone. Calhoun was a better back than Eastwood.
You sure are a sharp one spanky...😀
 
Back
Top