• Hi Guest, want to participate in the discussions, keep track of read/unread posts access private forums and more? Create your free account and increase the benefits of your eGriz.com experience today!

Obvious Question.

Ah Yat is the better QB.

Correct me if I am wrong but you are always the Jeff Disney, Brandon Neill, Fife is better guy are you not?

Wrong on all 3 if you were.
Partly right. Disney was not a D1 QB; Neill would have been a star if allowed to play.

Ah Yat had every chance to show it and he didn't.
 
Partly right. Disney was not a D1 QB; Neill would have been a star if allowed to play.

Ah Yat had every chance to show it and he didn't.
so i guess you think hauck is not a great coach? after his hire, you were guaranteeing great things. seems to me like the greatest thing so far was mcdowell leading the team when others couldn't.
 
That's all I need to know about your judgement on talent. Neill failed at Wyoming, he quit and couldn't beat out Edwards. Stars don't do that
 
And with that statement I now know to avoid anything else you have to say. He literally couldn't score against Portland State, the WORST Big Sky Defense.
This was my thought too. Early in the season I thought AY would be the guy because of his running abilities and I thought he could throw equally as good as Fife. It became painfully apparent to me that Fife was the better choice. The guy is gritty and sees the field way better. Also his scrambling ability is as good if not better just because he makes better decisions and knows when to tuck it.
I want AY to be the guy but he is not. If they force him next year it's not going to be a good year.
 
When compared to AhYat? 100%, amazing so many choose to ignore factual data (numbers dont lie) and their eyes.
My stance, the QB really didn't matter. The difference if Fife and Ah Yat, especially the last month, minimal. Starting Fife yesterday wasn't going to change the outcome.
 
Back
Top