HelenaHandBasket
Well-known member
Pac12 is suspending all athletics until Jan 1.
PlayerRep said:EverettGriz said:No argument on the preamble.
Still looking for a case law citation to suggest that a court -- ANY court -- would rule that protecting society's health is not a role of the federal government. Feel free to post when you locate.
*It's not really much of a discussion.
Well, whether the Preamble required the president or federal government to deal with the Covid, as LA suggested it did, was the discussion most of us were having.
Nothing in the Constitution or Bill of Rights requires the federal government to deal with healthcare, health or the virus. Health and healthcare are not mentioned in those documents.
Generally, the president can act in those areas only as authorized and directed by Congress. Significant powers, but still limited to what is authorized. That's why Trump couldn't tell states what to do, in terms of locking down or re-opening. He said he could, but then had to back down immediately as he didn't have that authority, and Dems, and Repubs, so told him.
Also, the Constitution basically says that States have all powers not specifically reserved and given to the federal government. The federal government does not have absolute power. See the Tenth amendment.
“The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.” US Constitution, Amendment X.
GrizLA said:PlayerRep said:Well, whether the Preamble required the president or federal government to deal with the Covid, as LA suggested it did, was the discussion most of us were having.
Nothing in the Constitution or Bill of Rights requires the federal government to deal with healthcare, health or the virus. Health and healthcare are not mentioned in those documents.
Generally, the president can act in those areas only as authorized and directed by Congress. Significant powers, but still limited to what is authorized. That's why Trump couldn't tell states what to do, in terms of locking down or re-opening. He said he could, but then had to back down immediately as he didn't have that authority, and Dems, and Repubs, so told him.
Also, the Constitution basically says that States have all powers not specifically reserved and given to the federal government. The federal government does not have absolute power. See the Tenth amendment.
“The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.” US Constitution, Amendment X.
I think you have put more words into my short post than is necessary. No where do I claim the Preamble as a source of law. It is a synthesis of the entire document and I merely suggested it as a guide for those with open minds and hearts. You being a corporate lawyer/parasite, I expected you could at least read a simple statement.
PlayerRep said:Sweden's GNP declined 8.6%. "Its GDP drop in the second quarter was lower than the 12.1 average experienced in the Eurozone, as well as the 11.9 average across the whole of the EU."