• Hi Guest, want to participate in the discussions, keep track of read/unread posts access private forums and more? Create your free account and increase the benefits of your eGriz.com experience today!

QB play

MrTitleist said:
I don't think McRae is a Griz anymore, at least, not a QB. Am I wrong? Larson is now a WR, as well.

Someone should tell Hauck that Larson is our best QB and the two guys tearing it up currently are not. Also, I heard from practice today that its obvious that Alex Verlanic is our best cornerback, but he hasn't gotten the chance yet.. :? :?
 
We need to give Kemp a couple of passing plays to run.

Message to opposing D's: Everytime we put in Kemp, he is going to run with the ball. Weber got that. So will others.
 
loyalgriz said:
Lotsa love said:
Kemp is much too good of an athlete to ride the pines. But, I think one of the reasons that he signed with Montana over many other schools who recruited him (including some FBS schools from what I hear) is that Bobby promised him a shot at playing QB.

If Kemp was smart, he would realize that he probably will not be a starter at QB for the Griz. No, I understand that Bobby has not even played him in real-game situations, except for a few predictable Wildcat plays. He has never really been given a chance to move the team, throw the ball, in a live situation. If Bobby would not allow us to play-down to inferior competition like he has done for years, we would be blowing our the likes of Sac. State, and UC Davis, and Gerald could be given a few series at QB to see what he could do. But, <sigh>, we know that this is not gonna happen with a Hauck-coached team.

Kemp should move to either DB or WR, in my opinion. He is quick, fast, and athletic. He could possible start at one of those positions next season if he made the move now. Just the way I see it.

Please provide examples of teams that give their 3rd QB live time during the season. It just doesn't happen. We are trying to figure out how to give the 2nd guy enough time.......let alone the third guy.....let it go...

no
 
ALPHAGRIZ1 said:
Jesus..... :roll: What credentials do YOU have to be making decisions on Kemp?

Look, we know your related, we get it but seriously try and be objective.

In practice he overthrows quite often then compensates for it by pitching a few in the ground.

Live reps? You play like you practice if it isnt getting done in practice it shows why hes only running the ball, the dude is an athlete and has some skills.......slinging the ball around doesnt look like one of the better ones he has.


Also yes I would prefer a QB that stays in the pocket those guys win games.

Lets look at the list of "mobile" QBs that were not able to win consistently nor win the big games

Vince Evans
Randall Cunningham
Doug Flutie
Rich Gannon
Michael Vick
Donovan McNabb
Vince Young
Fran Tarkington

You can have every one of those guys.


The only guy that was very mobile that I can think of that won a ton of games was

Steve Young and the reason he did is because he stayed in the pocket until he had to scramble, he was throw first run at a last resort. Non of the above were disciplined enough to do that.

I agree with Hauck.

John Elway was pretty mobile and did win a Super Bowl. Does he count? Just curious, has there ever been a black NFL QB that you liked? Marlin Briscoe, James Harris, Warren Moon, Steve McNair, Doug Williams....they all suck too according to your expert opinion, right? Nevermind you probably don't know who half of those names are and I don't care what your answer is. Maybe that explains the real reason you don't like Kemp....

Kemp isn't getting any live throwing reps (7 on 7 or 11 on 11)in practice because he is a freshman and Selle and Roper are getting all the throwin reps. That is a fact and rightly so since Roper and Selle are the rotating QBs. You are full of it when you say you've seen Kemp overthrow, then underthrow in practice. He is not throwin the rock in 7 on 7 or 11 on 11 in practice period (live reps).

Yes I know Kemp personally and have seen him play the QB position for years...much longer than you. Kemp has a big future ahead of him at Montana at QB. If believing that makes me biased, so be it. That being said again unlike you I believe Selle is doing a great job right now and Roper isn't hurting the team either. The Griz are 8-0 and getting better every week. And that credit goes to Bobby Hauck and his coaching staff.

You don't have to tell me where your credentials come from Alpha...you posts demonstrate time and time again that your credentials come straight outta your asssss......
 
kemajic said:
RobGriz said:
Actually his ball floats when he doesn't bring his hip through which causes him to cut off his follow through...just sayin.
OK, what causes the too frequent flutter balls that Selle throws?

Ok, I am not a QB coach, just happen to be the father of a QB and as such have been to a bunch of qb clinics and been around some great QB coaches (Dave Miller-Lakes High School-Father of Drew Miller) and listened. I just happened to know about the hip thing cause my son does it every once in a while. I know that when my sons ball flutters it is usually because he is not turning his wrist all the way over, which makes the fingers roll down the laces and causes the nice spiral. If a qb is trying to muscle the ball down the field they will sometimes grip the ball a little tight and that can also cause the flutter which relates directly to the arm strength of the qb, because when the reciever gets to or past the limit of the qb's range, sometimes said qb will try to muscle the ball to get enough on it to get it downfield. (Think John Edwards)
 
RobGriz said:
kemajic said:
OK, what causes the too frequent flutter balls that Selle throws?

Ok, I am not a QB coach, just happen to be the father of a QB and as such have been to a bunch of qb clinics and been around some great QB coaches (Dave Miller-Lakes High School-Father of Drew Miller) and listened. I just happened to know about the hip thing cause my son does it every once in a while. I know that when my sons ball flutters it is usually because he is not turning his wrist all the way over, which makes the fingers roll down the laces and causes the nice spiral. If a qb is trying to muscle the ball down the field they will sometimes grip the ball a little tight and that can also cause the flutter which relates directly to the arm strength of the qb, because when the reciever gets to or past the limit of the qb's range, sometimes said qb will try to muscle the ball to get enough on it to get it downfield. (Think John Edwards)
OK, so it's a Billings thing....
 
kemajic said:
RobGriz said:
Ok, I am not a QB coach, just happen to be the father of a QB and as such have been to a bunch of qb clinics and been around some great QB coaches (Dave Miller-Lakes High School-Father of Drew Miller) and listened. I just happened to know about the hip thing cause my son does it every once in a while. I know that when my sons ball flutters it is usually because he is not turning his wrist all the way over, which makes the fingers roll down the laces and causes the nice spiral. If a qb is trying to muscle the ball down the field they will sometimes grip the ball a little tight and that can also cause the flutter which relates directly to the arm strength of the qb, because when the reciever gets to or past the limit of the qb's range, sometimes said qb will try to muscle the ball to get enough on it to get it downfield. (Think John Edwards)
OK, so it's a Billings thing....

uh...sounds like as reasonable an explanation as any.
 
hoopmaster111 said:
ALPHAGRIZ1 said:
Jesus..... :roll: What credentials do YOU have to be making decisions on Kemp?

Look, we know your related, we get it but seriously try and be objective.

In practice he overthrows quite often then compensates for it by pitching a few in the ground.

Live reps? You play like you practice if it isnt getting done in practice it shows why hes only running the ball, the dude is an athlete and has some skills.......slinging the ball around doesnt look like one of the better ones he has.


Also yes I would prefer a QB that stays in the pocket those guys win games.

Lets look at the list of "mobile" QBs that were not able to win consistently nor win the big games

Vince Evans
Randall Cunningham
Doug Flutie
Rich Gannon
Michael Vick
Donovan McNabb
Vince Young
Fran Tarkington

You can have every one of those guys.


The only guy that was very mobile that I can think of that won a ton of games was

Steve Young and the reason he did is because he stayed in the pocket until he had to scramble, he was throw first run at a last resort. Non of the above were disciplined enough to do that.

I agree with Hauck.

John Elway was pretty mobile and did win a Super Bowl. Does he count? Just curious, has there ever been a black NFL QB that you liked? Marlin Briscoe, James Harris, Warren Moon, Steve McNair, Doug Williams....they all suck too according to your expert opinion, right? Nevermind you probably don't know who half of those names are and I don't care what your answer is. Maybe that explains the real reason you don't like Kemp....

Kemp isn't getting any live throwing reps (7 on 7 or 11 on 11)in practice because he is a freshman and Selle and Roper are getting all the throwin reps. That is a fact and rightly so since Roper and Selle are the rotating QBs. You are full of it when you say you've seen Kemp overthrow, then underthrow in practice. He is not throwin the rock in 7 on 7 or 11 on 11 in practice period (live reps).

Yes I know Kemp personally and have seen him play the QB position for years...much longer than you. Kemp has a big future ahead of him at Montana at QB. If believing that makes me biased, so be it. That being said again unlike you I believe Selle is doing a great job right now and Roper isn't hurting the team either. The Griz are 8-0 and getting better every week. And that credit goes to Bobby Hauck and his coaching staff.

You don't have to tell me where your credentials come from Alpha...you posts demonstrate time and time again that your credentials come straight outta your asssss......


You just lost all credibility with your BS post.


Nice try though.
 
1. The throw on-the-run is a skill that has to be developed through much practice and repetition.

While running, the passer must twist his torso perpendicular to the target in a quick, cocking motion. Many passers do not get their shoulders far enough around – while still running – especially when sprinting out in the opposite direction of their passing arm.

For every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction. The throwing motion and subsequent release must immediately follow the cocking motion. This uses the momentum of the motion to assist the throw, like loading and releasing a spring. Many times QBs hesitate, creating two distinct motions, back and forth, which depletes the momentum and causes the pass to sail or flutter.

When running in the same direction of the receiver, the passer does not have to “lead” the receiver. A lot of quarterbacks don’t realize this. It’s simple physics. The ball is already traveling that way when it’s released, so it naturally “leads” the receiver.

http://www.spreadoffense.com/ssp/sprint_out_pass

2. "he threw with a very tense upper body and he squeezes the ball hard, which can cause the ball to flutter or sail on him at times"

Tom Luginbill, ESPN http://sports.espn.go.com/ncaa/recruiting/football/news/story?id=4098507

3. My criterion when it was windy was to throw a spiral. ‘You can’t rush it, either. Slow down the motion. When you speed up and try to power the ball, you give up a certain amount of control. Your accuracy definitely suffers. You want to be nice and smooth. You’ll get through the wind better than if you try to muscle it.

Overgripping is the most frequent mistake I see among quarterbacks at all levels, including the pros. ‘I found the harder I’d squeeze, the less control I’d have. When you throw, your arm should move like a whip. It can’t move that way when the muscles are tense.

Phil Simms, New York Times http://fifthdown.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/01/15/how-to-stop-downward-spiral-for-eli-manning/?apage=2

4. If you’re interested in learning more about how to throw a tight spiral, you can consult this article in The Wall Street Journal http://online.wsj.com/article/SB119707054348217657.html.

Excerpts:

Physicists say a football needs to spin to be gyroscopically stable, but as soon as it’s airborne, wind and gravity will try to knock it from its axis and make it wobble like a slow bicycle. That a quarterback can throw one of these things 60 yards and hit a moving target “is just amazing,” says William Rae, professor emeritus of aerospace engineering at the University at Buffalo.

Simms has written a book called “Phil Simms on Passing” and tutored several promising quarterbacks (at no charge) from nearby schools. If he’d known what he knows now while he was still playing, he says, “I would have set records.”
 
Back
Top