• Hi Guest, want to participate in the discussions, keep track of read/unread posts access private forums and more? Create your free account and increase the benefits of your eGriz.com experience today!

JJ Trial

tnt said:
PolsonGrizFan said:
Paoli: Would it be fair to say you can't compartmentalize credibility? #johnsontrial Duerk objects, judge sustains.

nice one Paoli

I think Bell is about to burst into flames.
Click to expand...

I'm thinking if anyone wanted to find the two most un-credible witnesses in town for this diagnoses the couldn't have done better. Stratford has been discredited so many times its ridiculous and Bell has absolutley no qualifications to make a diagnoses for any of it.
Click to expand...

How so? Stratford is far more qualfied than Bell to make a psychiatric diagnosis. When was he discredited?
 
montanaguy said:
tnt said:
PolsonGrizFan said:
Paoli: Would it be fair to say you can't compartmentalize credibility? #johnsontrial Duerk objects, judge sustains.

nice one Paoli

I think Bell is about to burst into flames.
Click to expand...

I'm thinking if anyone wanted to find the two most un-credible witnesses in town for this diagnoses the couldn't have done better. Stratford has been discredited so many times its ridiculous and Bell has absolutley no qualifications to make a diagnoses for any of it.
Click to expand...

How so? Stratford is far more qualfied than Bell to make a psychiatric diagnosis. When was he discredited?
Click to expand...

Don't! It fits his agenda.
 
Ursus1 said:
I think Paolis only mistake was calling this last witness regarding PTSD...the recall by prosecution is leaving some real thoughts in jurors minds....they never would have had that shot if not for beign able to call rebuttal...should have closed with Jordy's dad......
Click to expand...

I think you might be right. Doesn't seem like much was gained here today for the defense.
 
Ursa Major said:
Ursus1 said:
I think Paolis only mistake was calling this last witness regarding PTSD...the recall by prosecution is leaving some real thoughts in jurors minds....they never would have had that shot if not for beign able to call rebuttal...should have closed with Jordy's dad......
Click to expand...

I think you might be right. Doesn't seem like much was gained here today for the defense.
Click to expand...

Something was gained, the judge just ruled for the defense.
 
Ursa Major said:
Ursus1 said:
I think Paolis only mistake was calling this last witness regarding PTSD...the recall by prosecution is leaving some real thoughts in jurors minds....they never would have had that shot if not for beign able to call rebuttal...should have closed with Jordy's dad......
Click to expand...

I think you might be right. Doesn't seem like much was gained here today for the defense.
Click to expand...
Not guilty verdict and everyone goes home.
Guilty verdict and only JJ doesn't get to go home.
The defense wouldn't be doing its job if they left anything to chance.
 
bluemarlin2 said:
Ursa Major said:
Ursus1 said:
I think Paolis only mistake was calling this last witness regarding PTSD...the recall by prosecution is leaving some real thoughts in jurors minds....they never would have had that shot if not for beign able to call rebuttal...should have closed with Jordy's dad......
Click to expand...

I think you might be right. Doesn't seem like much was gained here today for the defense.
Click to expand...

Something was gained, the judge just ruled for the defense.
Click to expand...
And Paoli got to say that line about compartmentalizing credibility. That was classic.
 
montanaguy said:
tnt said:
PolsonGrizFan said:
Paoli: Would it be fair to say you can't compartmentalize credibility? #johnsontrial Duerk objects, judge sustains.

nice one Paoli

I think Bell is about to burst into flames.
Click to expand...

I'm thinking if anyone wanted to find the two most un-credible witnesses in town for this diagnoses the couldn't have done better. Stratford has been discredited so many times its ridiculous and Bell has absolutley no qualifications to make a diagnoses for any of it.
Click to expand...

How so? Stratford is far more qualfied than Bell to make a psychiatric diagnosis. When was he discredited?
Click to expand...


Will Stratford used to be the go to guy for Forensic testimony not only here but nationally. He "was" an expert at the MMPI both administering and interpretting it. He has had more misses than hit in his evaluations. He hasn't been used much in the last 10 years. He put a few sex offenders back on the street that shopuld have been put down. I honestly can't remember the details. Most attorneys laugh when his name is bought up. Probably the best they could get on short notice. better than using a GP as a psychiatrist.....
 
Pretty thin if the prosecution is implying that the behavioral / emotional problems of JDoe is proof of the charges and nothing else. None of the doctors and councilors even agree what the proper diagnosis is. Proof? Even the "torn leggings" turned out not to have been torn. Lets tie this one off...
 
Jay-sus. Bell wrote down one thing, but diagnosed something else?

And, he did or did not treat, with Zoloft, which diagnosis?

And Zoloft is associated with higher risk of suicide ideation, and a Dr. is out there prescribing it for ... something, depending apparently on what's needed at trial?

Another State's witness explodes.
 
UMGriz75 said:
Jay-sus. Bell wrote down one thing, but diagnosed something else?

And, he did or did not treat, with Zoloft, which diagnosis?

And Zoloft is associated with higher risk of suicide ideation, and a Dr. is out there prescribing it for ... something, depending apparently on what's needed at trial?

Another State's witness explodes.
Click to expand...
+1
 
Watched Senor Stratford get "raped" in deposeetion by deefense on 9/11/2001. He looked very loco before it was all said and done...

stay thirsty amigos.....
 
Emily Adamson NBC MT ‏@EmilyNBCMT
Judge says jurors cell phones will be taken away tomorrow. #JohnsonTrial
 
If I understand it right, the prosecution's case has been basically proving that Doe has PTSD, and hoping the jury makes the connection that this proves rape??

Is this standard in rape trials like this?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Back
Top