There's no better sound in sports than the crack of a wooden bat. It makes the game more true. When I was growing up I never really used wooden bats. I had always used aluminum, so that's what I was used to. Even in legion when I played for the Glacier Twins, all I used was aluminum. They didn't start their wood bat tourney until the year after I was done playing with them. I then moved out west to Eugene, OR in 2001 and played for Lane Community College in the NWAACC (Northwest Athletic Association of Community Colleges) Conference. In 2000, the NWAACC Conference switched over to wooden bats. Coming from an area that didn't really use wood bats, it took quite some time to adjust to the wood bats. The sweet spot is smaller and the bats are less forgiving. With aluminum, you can hit the ball off the handle and still get a base hit out of it. With wood it's a different story. Yeah you hit more home runs and have a better average with aluminum bats, but that's not the way the game should be played. Wood bats make the game more competitive. It makes pitching and fielding very important, and you don't have as many blowout victories. It just makes the game that much better. The game should be played the way it's supposed to be, with WOOD bats.
As far as the cost goes, yeah in the end wood bats can become more expensive, with the breaking of wood bats. But they do make composite wood bats that don't break like regular wood. For example, at Lane, the team supplied "Baum Bats". Baum bats are the best composite wood bats on the market, and they hit just like wood. Same sound and everything, but they don't break. The team would get 6-8 new bats a year and we would use the new ones in games. In practice, we would use Baum bats from a year or two before, so we could save the new ones for the games. I bought my own personal bats that were solid wood that I used in games. But I would use the Baum bats in practice. There's virtually no difference between the two. They hit just like wood. And they're less costly than aluminum. For a good solid ash wood bat, you're looking at about $45-50/each, for maple you're looking at about $75-100/each. A Baum bat is $150/each or $125/each if you buy a box of 6. The solid wood bats may have a slight amount of more pop than the Baum bats, but Baum bats will last 10 times longer than a regular wood bat.
In my opinion, we should do away with aluminum bats and go back to wood. Think about it...An aluminum bat costs roughly $300, a Baum bat costs $125-150. If a team purchases say 6 bat a year for the team to use, aluminum bats will cost about $1,800. Where as the Baum bats will cost $750.
In conclusion, wood bats make the game more true and competive, they make the game safer, and they are also less expensive. Not to mention that if they started using wood bats in little league on up, not only would it make them BETTER hitters, they wouldn't have to make the adjustments when they got to the higher levels.\
I vote for the switch to WOOD.