I posted this on your substack, and thought I’d leave it here, too. With an addendum.
Brint, thank you for encouraging people to tamp down the hysteria following this loss. It might feel good to vent, but it won’t serve any useful purposes, especially when the targets of that will be student/athletes and coaches’ families, and none of them deserve that.
While I was running this morning, I was affected by my emotions of the game and season. My pace was slower and my running was a bit labored. It gave me more time to think.
I was thinking of asking a Q for the GFP: How are you talking to your kids about this loss and what are you showing them about difficult times?
I think those questions are still worth talking about and I would love to hear you guys kick that around.
While running and thinking (I went out for an hour, so I had a little time), I decided that the Bobcat win is a sign of how the page has fully turned, and probably did so a few years ago. I don’t expect to have another “The Streak,” but I feel like times have changed in FCS, and I am not so sure our program has changed with them. And two losses in a season to that program speaks volumes about where the Grizzlies are vs the rest of the FCS.
I don’t think the school would be served by a wholesale firing of the staff, tbh. I DO think if we’re really going to tout “the pride and tradition,” that it would be nice to approach it as succession planning. And our University is led by a man with the business acumen to do that.
Will that happen? I decided that it’s very unlikely because that’s not how head coaches become available to hire.
What’s more, I recall that at the outset of the season what I was really thinking was that NEXT season would be the one where the offense would have lofty expectations due to the maturation of the qb and hopefully an O line. I think the fantastic qb play and explosive offense lured me into lofty expectations a tad early.
I think the O actually over delivered this season.
The defense? Not so much. And I think that gets me to the point about times changing. I don’t think our defense has changed, and I think it needs to. This puts me squarely in Schmidt’s camp regarding the 3-3-5.
The simple fact is our defense hasn’t consistently played well enough against the top FCS teams. For a very long time.
What needs to happen? Should we fire the head coach or his staff?
I’m not so sure. And it doesn’t take long to arrive at why.
The fact is, this program played in a national championship recently, and had a deep playoff run this year. The team has missed the playoffs recently, too. But it’s not like the whole product is bad.
The head coach had demonstrated that he can change. We like to talk about “Bobby Ball,” but I don’t think we’ve seen it to the extent we did in Hauck 1.0. Plus the offense has clearly changed, and so has the approach to the offense overall.
If I’m the AD, I don’t think there are grounds to dismiss a guy for cause.
I DO think that the level of success and inability to get over the hump against the best teams warrants a discussion about expectations for the defense, and the program. And I think it would be a good idea to allow the current contract to expire, and go into the final year of the contract refusing to have a discussion about the future until the end of the season. That might risk a few recruits who want to play for certain people, but it also allows you free reign to let the world talk about the potential job opening and see who makes waves and shows they really want it.
It also allows the coach to exit gracefully.
That’s where I am at this morning after. Those feelings might change.
Hopefully the way I behave is something I will be proud to reflect on in the future.
I know the Internet is not a place known for thoughtful discussion, much less eGriz, where I limit my time, and am not afraid to pop in and drop a truth bomb now and then, especially when someone acting like an ahole richly deserves it.
But I am trying to be measured and rational and I think that the future of the program deserves that, whether or not my particular landing spot is where things go.
Go Griz!